Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Métodos de descomposición en
Economía utilizando STATA
Raúl Ramos
AQR-IREA (Universitat de Barcelona) & IZA
Métodos de descomposición en Economía utilizando STATA
Estructura de la presentación
Motivación
Oaxaca-Blinder
WM WH SMi SHi ˆH 2 ˆM1 ˆH1 SMi ˆM 2 ˆH 2
explic ada no explic ada
(c arac terís tic as ) (c oefic ientes )
Métodos de descomposición en Economía utilizando STATA
. bysort HOMBRE: sum LWAGE ANOSEST if LWAGE!=. & ANOSEST!=.
-> HOMBRE = 0
-> HOMBRE = 1
overall
group_1 6.752326 .0045491 1484.32 0.000 6.74341 6.761242
group_2 6.999458 .0038474 1819.25 0.000 6.991917 7.006999
difference -.2471321 .0059579 -41.48 0.000 -.2588095 -.2354548
endowments .0232102 .0029963 7.75 0.000 .0173376 .0290828
coefficients -.2717751 .0051093 -53.19 0.000 -.2817891 -.2617611
interaction .0014328 .0005592 2.56 0.010 .0003367 .0025288
Métodos de descomposición en Economía utilizando STATA
overall
group_1 6.752326 .0045491 1484.32 0.000 6.74341 6.761242
group_2 6.999458 .0038474 1819.25 0.000 6.991917 7.006999
difference -.2471321 .0059579 -41.48 0.000 -.2588095 -.2354548
endowments .0232102 .0029963 7.75 0.000 .0173376 .0290828
coefficients -.2717751 .0051093 -53.19 0.000 -.2817891 -.2617611
interaction .0014328 .0005592 2.56 0.010 .0003367 .0025288
overall
group_1 6.752326 .0045494 1484.23 0.000 6.743409 6.761243
group_2 6.999458 .0038476 1819.17 0.000 6.991917 7.006999
difference -.2471321 .0059583 -41.48 0.000 -.2588101 -.2354541
endowments -.0031307 .003501 -0.89 0.371 -.0099924 .0037311
coefficients -.2567434 .005005 -51.30 0.000 -.266553 -.2469337
interaction .0127419 .0014051 9.07 0.000 .009988 .0154958
Métodos de descomposición en Economía utilizando STATA
overall
group_1 6.752326 .0045494 1484.23 0.000 6.743409 6.761243
group_2 6.999458 .0038476 1819.17 0.000 6.991917 7.006999
difference -.2471321 .0059583 -41.48 0.000 -.2588101 -.2354541
endowments -.0031307 .003501 -0.89 0.371 -.0099924 .0037311
coefficients -.2567434 .005005 -51.30 0.000 -.266553 -.2469337
interaction .0127419 .0014051 9.07 0.000 .009988 .0154958
Omega = 1
Char -.0096113 -3.889115%
Coef .2440015 98.7332%
Int .0127419 5.155911%
Omega = 0
Char .0031307 1.266796%
Coef .2567434 103.8891%
Int -.0127419 -5.155911%
overall
group_1 6.752326 .0045494 1484.23 0.000 6.743409 6.761243
group_2 6.999458 .0038476 1819.17 0.000 6.991917 7.006999
difference -.2471321 .0059583 -41.48 0.000 -.2588101 -.2354541
explained -.0031307 .003501 -0.89 0.371 -.0099924 .0037311
unexplained -.2440015 .0050192 -48.61 0.000 -.253839 -.2341639
.
.
.
. oaxaca LWAGE ANOSEST EXPPOT EXPPOT2, by(HOMBRE) weight(1) nodetail
overall
group_1 6.752326 .0045494 1484.23 0.000 6.743409 6.761243
group_2 6.999458 .0038476 1819.17 0.000 6.991917 7.006999
difference -.2471321 .0059583 -41.48 0.000 -.2588101 -.2354541
explained .0096113 .0034659 2.77 0.006 .0028181 .0164044
unexplained -.2567434 .005005 -51.30 0.000 -.266553 -.2469337
Métodos de descomposición en Economía utilizando STATA
-> HOMBRE = 0
-> HOMBRE = 1
Omega = 1
Char -.0082834 -4.8347%
Coef .1925912 112.4076%
Int -.0129749 -7.572933%
Omega = 0
Char -.0212584 -12.40763%
Coef .1796163 104.8347%
Int .0129749 7.572933%
.
Métodos de descomposición en Economía utilizando STATA
. oaxaca LWAGE ANOSEST EXPPOT EXPPOT2, by(HOMBRE) weight(0)
overall
group_1 6.752326 .0045494 1484.23 0.000 6.743409 6.761243
group_2 6.999458 .0038476 1819.17 0.000 6.991917 7.006999
difference -.2471321 .0059583 -41.48 0.000 -.2588101 -.2354541
explained -.0031307 .003501 -0.89 0.371 -.0099924 .0037311
unexplained -.2440015 .0050192 -48.61 0.000 -.253839 -.2341639
explained
ANOSEST .0229593 .0029697 7.73 0.000 .0171387 .0287799
EXPPOT -.0454813 .0068799 -6.61 0.000 -.0589655 -.031997
EXPPOT2 .0193913 .0067165 2.89 0.004 .0062272 .0325554
unexplained
ANOSEST .1086091 .0159958 6.79 0.000 .0772579 .1399602
EXPPOT -.3237409 .0324256 -9.98 0.000 -.3872939 -.2601879
EXPPOT2 .2243474 .0191586 11.71 0.000 .1867972 .2618976
_cons -.253217 .0256104 -9.89 0.000 -.3034125 -.2030215
overall
group_1 6.752326 .0045494 1484.23 0.000 6.743409 6.761243
group_2 6.999458 .0038476 1819.17 0.000 6.991917 7.006999
difference -.2471321 .0059583 -41.48 0.000 -.2588101 -.2354541
Métodos de descomposición en Economía utilizando STATA
overall
group_1 6.752326 .0045495 1484.18 0.000 6.743409 6.761243 Variable TER PRIM
group_2 6.999458 .0038477 1819.12 0.000 6.991917 7.006999
difference -.2471321 .0059584 -41.48 0.000 -.2588105 -.2354538
explained .0076865 .003499 2.20 0.028 .0008286 .0145445 overall
unexplained -.2548186 .0049956 -51.01 0.000 -.2646099 -.2450274 group_1 6.752326 6.752326
explained group_2 6.9994581 6.9994581
ESTPRIM
ESTSEC
.032433
.0018083
.0032515
.001329
9.97
1.36
0.000
0.174
.0260602
-.0007966
.0388058
.0044131
difference -.24713211 -.24713211
EXPPOT -.0495804 .007483 -6.63 0.000 -.0642468 -.0349139 explained .00768652 .00768652
EXPPOT2 .0230256 .0079679 2.89 0.004 .0074087 .0386425 unexplained -.25481864 -.25481864
unexplained
ESTPRIM -.0650163 .0079946 -8.13 0.000 -.0806854 -.0493472 explained
ESTSEC -.0194887 .0028643 -6.80 0.000 -.0251025 -.0138748
EXPPOT -.250333 .0324129 -7.72 0.000 -.313861 -.1868049 ESTPRIM .03243298
EXPPOT2 .1663749 .0187925 8.85 0.000 .1295423 .2032075
_cons -.0863557 .0178037 -4.85 0.000 -.1212504 -.051461
ESTSEC .00180828 -.00164564
EXPPOT -.04958036 -.04958036
. EXPPOT2 .02302563 .02302563
ESTTER .03588689
. oaxaca LWAGE ESTSEC ESTTER EXPPOT EXPPOT2, by(HOMBRE) weight(0)
explained
ESTSEC -.0016456 .0012091 -1.36 0.173 -.0040154 .0007241
ESTTER .0358869 .0027258 13.17 0.000 .0305444 .0412294
EXPPOT -.0495804 .007483 -6.63 0.000 -.0642468 -.0349139
EXPPOT2 .0230256 .0079679 2.89 0.004 .0074087 .0386425
unexplained
ESTSEC .0003023 .0024749 0.12 0.903 -.0045483 .0051529
ESTTER .0259728 .003221 8.06 0.000 .0196598 .0322858
EXPPOT -.250333 .0324129 -7.72 0.000 -.313861 -.1868049
EXPPOT2 .1663749 .0187925 8.85 0.000 .1295423 .2032075
_cons -.1971357 .0181032 -10.89 0.000 -.2326174 -.1616541
Métodos de descomposición en Economía utilizando STATA
. oaxaca LWAGE ANOSEST EXPPOT EXPPOT2 normalize(ESTPRIM ESTSEC ESTTER), by(HOMBRE) weight(0)
(normalized: ESTPRIM ESTSEC ESTTER)
overall
group_1 6.752326 .0045497 1484.14 0.000 6.743409 6.761243
group_2 6.999458 .0038478 1819.08 0.000 6.991917 7.007
difference -.2471321 .0059586 -41.47 0.000 -.2588108 -.2354535
explained .0035228 .0035922 0.98 0.327 -.0035179 .0105634
unexplained -.2506549 .0049645 -50.49 0.000 -.2603851 -.2409247
explained
ANOSEST .0137584 .0019162 7.18 0.000 .0100027 .017514
EXPPOT -.0475207 .0071789 -6.62 0.000 -.0615912 -.0334502
EXPPOT2 .0207843 .0071965 2.89 0.004 .0066795 .0348892
ESTPRIM .0078755 .0009461 8.32 0.000 .0060212 .0097298
ESTSEC -7.80e-06 .000041 -0.19 0.849 -.0000882 .0000726
ESTTER .0086331 .0009322 9.26 0.000 .0068061 .0104601
unexplained
ANOSEST -.0840635 .0287433 -2.92 0.003 -.1403994 -.0277276
EXPPOT -.2490752 .0323043 -7.71 0.000 -.3123905 -.1857598
EXPPOT2 .1628606 .0193317 8.42 0.000 .1249712 .20075
ESTPRIM -.042871 .0072424 -5.92 0.000 -.0570659 -.0286761
ESTSEC -.0067038 .0015754 -4.26 0.000 -.0097915 -.0036161
ESTTER .025924 .0032397 8.00 0.000 .0195744 .0322736
_cons -.056726 .037474 -1.51 0.130 -.1301737 .0167216
Métodos de descomposición en Economía utilizando STATA
. oaxaca LWAGE ANOSEST EXPPOT EXPPOT2, by(HOMBRE) weight(0) model1(heckman, twostep select (OCUP= NATIVO SOLTERO ED
> (heckman, twostep select (OCUP= NATIVO SOLTERO EDAD NMIEM7))
overall
group_1 6.791242 .0201357 337.27 0.000 6.751776 6.830707
group_2 7.229495 .0103095 701.25 0.000 7.209289 7.249701
difference -.4382532 .0226215 -19.37 0.000 -.4825906 -.3939159
explained .011543 .0045549 2.53 0.011 .0026156 .0204704
unexplained -.4497963 .0221315 -20.32 0.000 -.4931733 -.4064193
explained
ANOSEST .0597605 .0039885 14.98 0.000 .0519432 .0675777
EXPPOT -.0694218 .0064712 -10.73 0.000 -.0821051 -.0567385
EXPPOT2 .0212043 .0035783 5.93 0.000 .0141911 .0282176
unexplained
ANOSEST .0335772 .0282256 1.19 0.234 -.0217441 .0888984
EXPPOT -.203953 .0403399 -5.06 0.000 -.2830176 -.1248883
EXPPOT2 -.0736814 .0267852 -2.75 0.006 -.1261793 -.0211834
_cons -.2057391 .0356934 -5.76 0.000 -.2756969 -.1357813
Métodos de descomposición en Economía utilizando STATA
. nopomatch ANOSEST EXPPOT EXPPOT2, outcome(LWAGE) by(HOMBRE) sd replace
*****************************************************************
***** Gap in ANOSEST EXPPOT EXPPOT2 decomposition
*****************************************************************
D =.03659748
D0 =.03749842
DM =-.00001405
DF =.00011499
DX =-.00100188
*****************************************************************
percM =.99636258
percF =.99817685
*****************************************************************
Calculating Standard Deviation
Std.error DO = .00072236
Métodos de descomposición en Economía utilizando STATA
. nopomatch ANOSEST EXPPOT EXPPOT2, outcome(WAGE) by(HOMBRE) sd replace
*****************************************************************
***** Gap in ANOSEST EXPPOT EXPPOT2 decomposition
*****************************************************************
D =.27070513
D0 =.28253065
DM =.00024646
DF =.0007391
DX =-.01281108
*****************************************************************
percM =.99636258
percF =.99817685
*****************************************************************
Calculating Standard Deviation
Std.error DO = .00692002
Métodos de descomposición en Economía utilizando STATA
. rqdeco LWAGE ANOSEST EXPPOT EXPPOT2, by(HOMBRE) qlow(0.1) qhigh(0.9) qstep(0.1) vce(boot) reps(2) noprint
Fitting base model
(bootstrapping ..)
.4
.4
.3
.35
Log wage effects
.2
.3
.1
0
.25
0 .2 .4 .6 .8 1
Quantile
.2
D E U
E Q P QP
U Q P QP
D = difference in differential
E = difference in predicted gap
U = difference in residual gap
Q = quantity effect
P = price effect
QP = interaction Q x P
Difference in (components of) differentials:
Métodos de descomposición en Economía utilizando
dD dE STATA
dC dEC
. smithwelch est2006M est2006H est2009M est2009H, detail Total -.0060013 .0024382 -.0073548 -.0010847
ANOSEST .1319002 .0229215 .1047036 .0042751 ANOSEST -.0028438 -.0060049 .0042832 -.0011221
EXPPOT -.3688332 -.0454705 -.3407522 .0173894 EXPPOT .0036177 7.52e-06 .0036108 -5.97e-07
EXPPOT2 .2435752 .019369 .2331294 -.0089233 EXPPOT2 .0016642 .0065639 -.0036595 -.0012401
_cons -.2537609 0 -.2537609 0 _cons 0 0 0 0
Total -.2471187 -.0031799 -.2566801 .0127413 Total .0024382 .0005665 .0042345 -.0023628
dC D E C EC
Sample 2 D E C EC
ANOSEST .0057979 .005077 .0006876 .0000333
ANOSEST .1337551 .0200777 .1105015 .0031758 EXPPOT -.0864155 -.0030433 -.0826341 -.000738
EXPPOT -.4474175 -.0418527 -.4271677 .0216029 EXPPOT2 .0229236 -2.87e-06 .0229268 -2.82e-07
EXPPOT2 .2639641 .0210333 .256053 -.0131222 _cons .0503392 0 .0503392 0
_cons -.2034218 0 -.2034218 0
Total -.0073548 .0020308 -.0086806 -.000705
Total -.2531201 -.0007417 -.2640349 .0116566
dEC D E C EC
dE D E C EC
dC D E C EC
Métodos de descomposición en Economía utilizando STATA
Síntesis
• search inequality
inequal, rspread, glcurve, descogini, ineqerr, kdensity,
akdensity, changemean, … y mucho más