Culture defines acceptable and appropriate behaviors in an
organization. As such, it is a management resource that can be used to meet organizational objectives, just like knowledge, machinery, raw materials, dollars, and human resources. Before attempting any kind of culture change initiative, the organization needs to know what the culture is and how it works, what type of culture would best support organizational strategy, recognize and use the levers that influence culture, and be clear about whether it wants to change the culture. The culture audit is the tool to use to get at the substance of an organization’s culture so that the organization understands where and how to drive change toward the preferred culture. COMMON ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURES Here are some common descriptions of various kinds of organizational cultures. As you read them, consider what words might be ideal descriptions for your organization given its strategy and mission. Do the outward expressions of culture that you have observed support the described ideal? Also note that few of these cultures could be directly described as bad or good for an organization. However, some are more appropriate for certain kinds of organizations than others. Safety: A safety culture conducts its work with particular attention to the protection of workers, equipment, and the environment.
Quality: A quality-oriented culture conducts work with attention to
the quality of the organization’s products and services and prides itself on being the best in the business. Organizations with a quality culture continuously strive to do better.
Ethical: An ethical culture stresses ethical behavior. The employees
of ethical organizations are expected to follow a code of conduct and deal honestly with other employees, clients, and the public. Technology-driven: A technology-driven culture uses state-of-the- art technology to provide products and services to customers. Organizations with this type of culture pride themselves on being up-to-date with the latest in technology.
Innovation: Innovation cultures are willing to take risks on new
ideas, processes, and products to stay on the cutting edge. Organizations that have this kind of culture are willing to be wrong, or experience failures once in a while to be open to the new discoveries that drive their ultimate success.
Customer service: Organizations that are customer-service
oriented focus on customer needs and expectations for their products and services. These organizations focus on keeping customers happy because they want to encourage repeat customers who will make referrals. Caring and compassion: Cultures that are characterized by the terms “caring” and “compassion” are particularly attentive to the feelings and needs of the people they serve, especially in vulnerable or high-need situations. The emergency ward example given previously could be described as a caring and compassionate culture.
Team: Team cultures value the heightened effectiveness of a
diverse group of people who pool their individual talents to achieve more and better results than individuals can alone. Represented employee In a represented-employee culture, a union speaks with one voice on behalf of its constituent member employees.
Military: Military culture is characterized by strict chains of
command and the following of orders from persons in superior positions. Constructive: In a constructive culture, employees are highly collegial with one another. They are expected to help each other reach high degrees of job satisfaction, personal and group achievement, and social or relationship ties.
Passive-defensive: In a passive-defensive culture, members feel
they must act in a safe way to avoid personal risk. This type of culture is characterized by individuals who seek approval, avoid risk, and acknowledge their dependence on others.
Aggressive-defensive-competitive: In this type of culture,
members are expected to be engaged in highly energetic execution of their roles and be forceful to protect themselves and achieve individual goals. WHAT’S IN A CULTURE AUDIT The phases of an audit are selecting an audit instrument or tool, collecting data, analyzing data, and preparing recommendations for change. The heart of an audit, however, is to uncover values and beliefs through interviews, focus groups, surveys, and direct observations of people. The areas most frequently examined in a culture audit include:
1) Organizational mission, vision, and values.
2) Understanding of and extent of buy-in to mission, vision, and
values.
3) How values are symbolized.
4) Value differences between the organization and its competitors.
5) Identification of key measures of success
type of leadership required.
6) The behaviors and attitudes of management and leadership.
7) Background of top managers, including schooling, time with the
organization, job experiences, current duties and status, and career path policies, procedures, training requirements, and recognition systems that support or inhibit the ideal culture and behaviors.
8) Incidents and examples that illustrate what is really important to
the organization.
9) Shared language or terminology.
10) Other strategic influences in the environment, such as competitive or allied organizations that may influence behavior cultural heritage or history since founding.
11) Organization’s structure and its relation to culture and
strategy.
12) Behaviors that reinforce core values
identification of subcultures and their roles. Using a valid and comprehensive process and appropriate instruments will give a global perspective on the current state of the culture. Alternatively, you can carry out an audit on a smaller scale by selecting only one or two characteristics or only one part of the organization. METHODS AND INSTRUMENTS The most common methods are: 1) Compiling existing data, such as mission statements, sales and safety records, customer satisfaction reports, productivity measures, and so forth. 2) Facilitating focus groups (see the sidebar Focus Groups on Culture at left for some examples of questions to ask focus groups). 3) Administering surveys in which organizational members and other stakeholders (such as vendors and customers) rate the degree to which behaviors align with ideals. PRODUCT OF A CULTURE AUDIT The end product of the culture audit is the report, which will give direction to making decisions for improvement. To prepare the report, take the following steps:
1) Analyze the data and report results statistically using visuals.
Develop tables and figures, such as bar graphs, to graphically show strong and weak areas. Remember that it’s important to present data that meets the interests of your audience.
2) Analyze trends in the responses given in focus groups.
3) Using the list of shared culture elements (values; mission, goals, and objectives; rewards and punishments).
4) Keeping the prepared reports for future reference.