Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Rezumat
Arhitectura se definete ntr-un mod clasic ca form
construit, opunndu-se spaiului liber prin marcarea
limitei dintre nuntru i afar. Anvelopanta reprezin
t o limit material ntre cele dou tipuri de zone
crora li se asociaz seturi diferite de activiti, com
portamente i triri.
n prezent constatm ns apariia unei tendine de
dematerializare a limitei care devine difuz, transformndu-se ea nsi n spaiu conceptual i negociind
raportul dintre nuntru i afar.
Pentru a exemplifica acest tip de situaii, ne vom
ndrepta atenia ctre depirea limitelor fizice ale
muzeului i prelungirea activitilor desfurate de
acesta n spaiul public al strzii. Strada trece astfel de
la rolul su de zon de tranziie la a fi valorificat din
punct de vedere cultural i la modificarea tipului de
activiti i percepii asociate acesteia. Devine prilej
pentru realizarea unei arhitecturi temporare ale crei
caracteristici i implicaii - la nivel arhitectural, urba
nistic dar i sociologic i antropologic - urmrim a le
descoperi.
Cuvinte cheie: muzeu, spaiu public, limit, discurs
muzeal, ieirea n strad, ntre muzeu i strad
anda.sfintes@gmail.com
Abstract
Architecture is defined classically as built form, opposed
to the open space by marking the threshold between
inside and outside. The enclosure represents a material
delimitation between the two areas which have differ
ent activities, behaviors and experiences assigned to
them.
In the present time, we witness a tendency ofdematerializing the threshold which becomes diffuse and turns
itself into a conceptual space, negotiating the inside/
outside interrelationship.
In order to exemplify this kind of situations, we shall
concentrate upon the museum which breaks its physical
limits and takes out its activities into the public space,
into the street which thus converts from transition zone
to being exploited at a cultural level. Hereby we also
witness the modification of the common type of activi
ties and cognition that the street relates to. These facts
avail the emergence of a temporal architecture and in
this article we wish to expose the characteristics and the
architectural, sociological and anthropological implica
tions of the relationships between museums and public
space.
Keywords: museum, public space, threshold, curatorial
discourse, taking it to the street, between museum and
street
Studii i cercetri tiinifice de arhitectur i urbanism / Architectural and Urban Research Studies / ARGUMENT 159
prezentare n cadrul sesiunii de comunicri tiinifice cu participare internaional Experimente urbane Evenimente
culturale, organizat de Universitatea de Arhitectur i Urbanism Ion Mincu (UAUIM), Bucureti, 28-29 martie 2012,
publicat n Daniela Rdulescu-Andronic (coord.), Argument, nr. 5/2013, pag. 159-178 http://argument.uauim.ro/
numere/5/108/
Trim n epoca simultaneitii: trim n epoca juxtapu- We are in the epoch of simultaneity: we are in the epnerii epoca lui aproape" i departe", epoca luicot-la- och of juxtaposition, the epoch of the near and far, of
cot"'epoca dispersiei. (Michel Foucault)
the side-by-side, of the dispersed. (Michel Foucault)
Introducere
Introduction
Discuia despre muzeul din strad pornete de la reconceptualizarea ideii de limit n arhitectur. n mod
tradiional, limita marcheaz diferena dintre nun
tru i afar, separnd att tipuri de zone ct i seturi
diferite de activiti, comportamente i triri asociate
acestora. n prezent, constatm ns apariia unei ten
dine de dematerializare a limitei care devine difuz,
transformndu-se ea nsi n spaiu conceptual i ne
gociind raportul dintre cele dou spaii. n acest con
text, muzeul din strad se refer la relaia muzeului
cu spaiul public, la activitile muzeale care se pre
lungesc, ntr-o form sau alta, dincolo de perimetrul
strict delimitat de anvelopanta cldirii i la formele
arhitecturale care nsoesc i exprim aceast pre
lungire. Prsindu-i limitele fizice, muzeul ajunge s
ocupe un spaiu-limit, ambiguu, cu un statut neclar
(att din punct de vedere spaial ct i temporal), care
faciliteaz, astfel, activarea i participarea la o serie de
realiti paralele, n funcie nu numai de dorina curatorial, ci, mai ales, de privitor.
Foucault definete n articolul su,Of Other Spaces",
heterotopiile drept locuri aflate n afara oricrui loc, le
gate de acestea dar, n acelai timp, opuse; locuri ale
acumulrii i juxtapunerii de spaii inclusiv incompa
tibile (Foucault i Miskowiec 1986) i recunoate mu
zeele drept astfel de heterotopii. Muzeul i introduce
vizitatorii ntr-o realitate paralel, n care timpul i
spaiul capt alte sensuri i dimensiuni. Simultane
itatea legturii (prin experienele proprii, anterioare,
cu care pete fiecare dintre vizitatori n spaiul mu
zeal) i deprtrii de realitatea de zi cu zi (prin dife
rena dintre spaiul i timpul real i spaiul i timpul
160 Universitatea de Arhitectur i Urbanism "Ion Mincu" / "Ion Mincu' University of Architecture and Urban Planning
Studii i cercetri tiinifice de arhitectur i urbanism / Architectural and Urban Research studie / ARGUMENT
n acest articol, vom ridica problema tipurilor de relaii care se stabilesc ntre muzeu i spaiul public, ur
mrind identificarea scopului i implicaiilor acestora.
Ne vom axa, n primul rnd, pe analiza rolului arhitec
turii, al amenajrilor urbane i contextului creat prin
spaiul construit n cadrul acestor relaii.
162
Studii i cercetri tiinifice de arhitectur i urbanism / Architectural and Urban Research Studia / ARGUMENT 163
164
Studii i cercetri tiinifice de arhitectur i urbanism / Architectural and Urban Research Studiem / ARGUMENT
e sitatea de Arhitectur i Urbanism Ion Mincu" / "Ion Mincu" University of Architecture and Urban Planning
Studii i cercetri tiinifice de arhitectur i urbanism / Architectural and Urban Research Studies / ARGUMENT 167
ersitatea de Arhitectur i Urbanism Ion Mincu" / "Ion Mincu" University of Architecture and Urban Planning
Museum o piaa deasupra creia leviteaz muzeul propriu-zis, astfel nct s fie scoase n evidena cmpiile din
deprtare i s fie ncurajat micarea neprogramat,
spontan, la nivel urban (http://www.mmaltzan.com/).
La The Riverside Museum din Glasgow, zona din faa mu
zeului a fost transformat n spaiu civic i folosit ntrun mod informai, pentru a atrage un segment de popu
laie mai greu accesibil, precum ciclitii i skateboarderi
(Fitzgerald 2012). Evenimentele desfurate aici creeaz
o legtur puternic ntre muzeu i comunitatea pe care
acesta o deservete.
intr-o aceeai ordine de idei putem meniona i con
cursul Young Architects Program, desfurat de Muse
um of Modern Art (MoMA) i MoMA PS1 din New York
i, din 2011, i de Museo nazionale delle arti del XXI secolo (MAXXI) din Roma. Tema concursului, lansat pri
ma dat n 1999, const n proiectarea unei arhitecturi
experimentale, temporare, care s fie, n acelai timp,
spaiu de recreere, de ntrunire, de desfurare a unor
evenimente conexe i care s ocupe curtea MoMA PS1/
piaa din faa MAXXI, prelungind activitatea exterioar
spre interior ntr-un mod provocator, dinamic i chiar
i distractiv"5 (trad, ns., http://www.moma.org/explore/
inside_out/2011/07/01/introducing-the-young-architects-program-international/). Directorul MoMA, Glenn
Lowry, privete acest concurs i construirea proiectului
de pe locul I drept un mod de a da ceva napoi comu
nitii (http://momaps1.org/yap/), stabilind astfel relaii
puternice ntre muzeu, ora i oameni, chiar i atunci
cnd acetia nu au neaprat calitatea de vizitator. Pentru
aceasta, de exemplu, proiectul ctigtor la Roma din
2012 - UNIRE/UNITE (care introducea, printr-o propune
re de mobilier urban, exerciiul fizic i jocul n viaa de
zi cu zi) - a fost reconstruit ulterior pe strzile oraului.
Tot drept spaii intermediare pot fi numite i faciliti
le publice precum magazine de suveniruri, restaurante
i cafenele care atrag, la rndul lor, o serie de vizitatori
aflai nu neaprat n cutare de informaii, dornici de a
nva ceva, ci care caut, mai degrab, moduri de pe-
Studii i cercetri tiinifice de arhitectur i urbanism / Architectural and Urban Research Studies / ARGUMENT
see the Seine and the Eiffel Tower from). Even if these
facilities may be considered to mark the decline of the
institution by polluting the cultural experience (Fleming
2005, 59), their presence emphasizes the ambiguity of
the area surrounding the main exhibition and the social
work done by museums through informal extension of
their activities. The visual relationships mentioned here
help the museum integrate organically within the city.
The street as seen from the museum
The museum architecture is usually opaque, demanded
by the necessity of assuring the proper conservation of
the displayed objects. Two of the main conservation re
quirements are those of keeping the objects away from
direct sunlight and of controlling the temperature and
humidity. The emergence of new types of museums that
don't focus on the object (which can even lack or have
less value attached) led to the insertion of transparen
cies, although with some constraints (imposed by the
necessity of alienating oneself from the exterior in order
to understand the curatorial discourse). Otherwise, cov
ering enclaves under a transparent membrane keeps
the necessary opaqueness while transforming the space
between them into a mediate space, organically con
nected with the outside.
The problem of transparency in museum architecture
opens up also discussions about the connection be
tween museum ar-d street, but this time in reverse, with
the attention F.:,ng dispersed and not concentrated on
the object af ,n the case of the museum as seen from
the public space. Transparency allows the creation of
a visual connection and communication, of continuity
between spaces having different statuses and functions.
The dialogue between street and museum can represent
a way of keeping the anchorage in the present time or,
on the contrary, of emphasizing the return to an ideal
past. At The National Museum of the Romanian Peas
ant, for example, the transparent windows situated at
the first floor open up, first of all, towards nature. The
building, drawn back from the street, and the vegeta-
Universitatea de Arhitectur i Urbanism "Ion Mincu" / Ion Mincu University of Architecture and Urban Planning
Studii i cercetri tiinifice de arhitectur i urbanism / Architectural and Urban Research Studies / ARGUMENT
Muzeul - strad
Ieirea muzeului n ntmpinarea vizitatorilor poate n
semna inclusiv ocuparea strzii cu o serie de spaii i
funciuni menite s atrag publicul ntr-un mod mai pu
in formal, organic. Ptrunderea n muzeu se face atunci
fr a sesiza la fel de dramatic diferenele de statut din
tre interior i exterior datorit spaiilor intermediare ce
mprumut caracteristicile ambelor i fac trecerea mai
puin perceptibil. Acest lucru conduce la creterea ac
cesibilitii, la atragerea unui numr mai mare de vizita
tori, chiar i din cadru unor segmente de populaie ce nu
se numr printre vizitatorii obinuii.
Un prim exemplu ar fi acela al prevederii unei intrri co
mune i al extinderii Complexul Muzeal Joanneum din
Graz, Austria - alctuit din Muzeul de Istorie Natural, Bi
blioteca Regional din Styria i Noua Galerie de Art Con
temporan - sub curtea comun celor trei cldiri. Cti
gtorii concursului desfurat n 2006, Nieto Sobejano
Arquitectos, au plecat de la dinamismul care anim su
prafeele orizontale ale oraului
(http://www.dezeen.com/2012/01/02/joanneum-museum-extension-by-nieto-sobejano-arquitectos-andeep-architekten/) i au propus o extindere aproape
imperceptibil. Se pstreaz planeitatea circulaiei, dar
traseul liniar este ntrerupt n anumite puncte, strnind
curiozitatea i introducnd alte faciliti publice, conexe
funciunilor principale ale celor trei cldiri existente.
Un alt exemplu ar fi Exhibition Road, o strad de dimen
siuni considerabile, din Londra, care leag obiective
importante la nivelul oraului, precum muzee, institute
culturale, colegii etc. Strada reprezint mai mult dect o
legtur fizic, ntruct evenimentele (inter-instituionale) care au loc aici au drept scop crearea unei identiti
a locului prin implicarea activ a audienei. Prin desf
urarea de programe incitante i neateptate, se urm
rete att nsuirea de cunotine, ct i generarea i
mprtirea acestora (http://www.exhibitionroad.com).
Ca puncte tari ale iniiativei sunt notate, n primul rnd,
diversitatea publicului implicat i posibilitatea extinderii
activitilor culturale dup ncheierea programului mu-
Universitatea de Arhitectur i Urbanism "Ion Mincu" / "Ion Mincu" University of Architecture and Urban Planning
Studii i cercetri tiinifice de arhitectur i urbanism / Architectural and Urban Research Studie'. / ARGUMENT
Universitatea de Arhitectur i Urbanism "Ion Mincu" / "Ion Mincu' University of Architecture and Urban Planning
Studii i cercetri tiinifice de arhitectur i urbanism / Architectural and Urban Research Studie./ ARGUMEN
Concluzii
Conclusions
Universitatea de Arhitectur i Urbanism "Ion Mincu" / "Ion Mincu" University of Architecture and Urban Planning
Bibliografie / Bibliography
American Association of Museums, 2012, T,endsWa,ch 20,2: Museums and the Pulse of the Future. American Asso
ciation of Museums, http://www.aam-us.org/docs/center-for-the-future-of-museums/2012 trends watch final
pdf?sfvrsn=0
Arts Council England, 2009, Beyond Their Walls. London: Arts Council England, http://www.artscouncil.org.uk/publiy
cation_archive/beyond-their-walls/.
BAL, Mieke, 2006, Exposing the Public, in A Companion to Museum Studies, ed. Sharon MacDonald 525-542
Blackwell Companions in Cultural Studies. Cornwall: Blackwell Pub.
BOLLO, Alessandro i Luca Dal Pozzolo, 2005, "Analysis of Visitor Behaviour Inside the Museum: An Empirical Study"
In Proceedings of the 8th International Conference on Arts and Cultural Management. Montreal.
http://neumann.hec.ca/aimac2005/PDF_Text/BolloA_DalPozzoloL.pdf.
CONOVER, Megan, 2006, "Portability: Making Art an Urban Event". Masters of Architecture, University of Cincinnati:
The School of Architecture and Interior Design. http://etd.ohiolink.edu/view.cgi?acc_num=ucin 1147803548.
CRANE, Susan A., 2006, "The Conundrum of Ephmerality:Time, Memory, and Museums."n A Companion to Museum
Studies, ed. Sharon MacDonald, 98-109. Blackwell Companions in Cultural Studies. Cornwall: Blackwell Pub.
FITZGERALD, Lawrence, 2012, "Riverside Museum, Glasgow." Museum Practice. http://www.museumsassociation.
org/museum-practice/your-outdoor-case-studies/15062012-riverside-museum.
FLEMING, David, 2005, "Creative Space" n Reshaping Museum Space: Architecture, Design, Exhibitions, ed. Suzanne
MacLeod, 53-61. London and New York: Taylor & Francis.
FOUCAULT, Michel i Jay MISKOWIEC, 1986, "Of Other Spaces."Diacritics 16 (No. 1): 22-27.
HOOPER-GREENHILL, Eilean, 2006, "Studying Visitors" in A Companion to Museum Studies, ed. Sharon MacDonald,
362-376. Blackwell Companions in Cultural Studies. Cornwall: Blackwell Pub.
MACDONALD, Sharon, 2006, "Expanding Museum Studies: An lntroduction."n A Companion to Museum Studies, ed.
Sharon MacDonald, 1-12. Blackwell Companions in Cultural Studies. Cornwall: Blackwell Pub.
MASON, Rhiannon, 2006, "Cultural Theory and Museum Studies"n A Companion to Museum Studies, ed. Sharon Ma
cDonald, 17-32. Blackwell Companions in Cultural Studies. Cornwall: Blackwell Pub.
MUNTEANU, Radu-llarion,"Muzeulranului Romn -Tur Personal", www.LiterNet.ro.http://destinatii.liternet.ro/articol/6/Radu-llarion-Munteanu/Muzeul-Taranului-Roman-tur-personal.html.
OPREA, Delia,"Muzeulranului Romn -Tur Personal", www.LiterNet.ro.http://destinatii.liternet.ro/articol/31/DeliaOprea/Muzeul-Taranului-Roman-tur-personal.html.
PSARRA, Sophia, 2005,"Spatial Culture, Way-finding and the Educational Message.The Impact of Layout on the Spa
tial, Social and Educational Experiences of Visitors to Museums and Galleries." In Reshaping Museum Space: Architec
ture, Design, Exhibitions, ed. Suzanne MacLeod, 78-94. London and New York: Taylor & Francis.
RAVELLI, Louise, 2006, Museum Texts: Comunication Frameworks. Prima ediie. Taylor & Francis e-Library.
SFINTE, Anda-loana, 2012, "Muzeul ranului Romn: Arhitectur, Discurs, Interpretare". Lucrare de disertaie, Mas
ter Antropologie, Bucureti: coala Naional de Studii Politice i Administrative.
SILVERMAN, Lois H., 2009, The Social Work of Museums. Taylor & Francis e-Library.
SMITH, Catherine, 2001, "Looking for Liminality in Architectural Space." Limen (No. 1). http://limen.mi2.hr/nmen1-2001/catherine_smith.html.
,
VERGO, Peter, 2006, "Introduction." In The New Museology, ed. Peter Vergo. 6th ed. Reaktion Books.
WHYBROW, Nicolas, 2011, Art and the City. London: I. B. Tauris & Co Ltd.
Studii i cercetri tiinifice de arhitectur i urbanism / Architectural and Urban Research Studies / ARGUMENT 177
Webografie / Webography
Arts Council England www.artscouncil.org.uk/
Ashes and Snow http://www.ashesandsnow.org/
Dezeen Magazine http://www.dezeen.com/
Exhibition Road http://www.exhibitionroad.com/
MichaelMaltzan Architecture http://www.mmaltzan.com/
MoMA PS 1 http://momaps1 .org/
Museum of Copenhagen http://www.copenhagen.dk/
Museums and the Web http://www.museumsandtheweb.com/
Muzeul Naional al ranului Romn www.muzeultaranuluiroman.ro/
The Homeless Museum of Art http://www.homelessmuseum.org/
The Museum of Modem Art http://www.moma.org/
The Temporary Museum of Permanent Change http://www.museumofchange.org/
Schaulager http://www.schaulager.org/
Sry/epa/-/c http://www.stylepark.com/
Universitatea de Arhitectur i Urbanism "Ion Mincu" / "Ion Mincu" University of Architecture and Urban Planning