Evaluarea articolului / PAPER REVIEW FORM

Numele revistei / Name of the Journal: Jurnal Medical Braovean

Articol / Paper Title:
Autori / Authors:

Referent / Reviewer:
Recomandarea
referentului
stiintific
Reviewer
recommendation

Acceptat / Accepted
Acceptat dup modificri minore /Accepted with minor
revisions
Acceptat dup modificri majore /Accepted with major
revisions
Respins / Rejected
Apreciai calitatea Pe o scala de la 0 la 1000
articolului
On a scale from 0 to 100
Overall Reviewer
Manuscript Rating:
Aprecierea
Obiective n concordana cu obiectivele revistei
articolului
da nu
in mica masura
in mare masura
Comments
to Useful and relevant to journal aims
Editor:
yes
no
to a lesser extend
to a major extend
Respectarea aspectelor etice
da nu
in mica masura
in mare masura
Ethically sound
yes
no
to a lesser extend
to a major extend
Calitatea stiintifica a cercetarii stiintifice determin o
contributie reala la transferul de cunostiinte in
domeniu
da nu
in mica masura
in mare masura
Significant contribution to international knowledge
(transferability)
yes
no
to a lesser extend
to a major extend
Articolul este prezentat intr-o forma accesibila, usor de
inteles
da nu
in mica masura
in mare masura
Accurate and understandable presentation
yes
no
to a lesser extend
to a major extend
Bibliografia este introdusa conform regulilor impuse de
politica revistei
da nu
in mica masura
in mare masura
Accurate and complete referencing
yes
no
to a lesser extend
to a major extend
Comentarii pentru
autor
Comments
to
Author:
Comentarii

confidentiale
pentru editori
Confidential
Comments to the

Evaluarea articolului / PAPER REVIEW FORM

Numele revistei / Name of the Journal: Jurnal Medical Braovean
Editor
Reevaluarea
articolului
Other revision

Sunteti dispus sa reevaluati manuscrisul dup ce au

fost effectuate modificarile solicitate
da nu
Would you be willing to review a revision of this
manuscript?
yes
no