Sunteți pe pagina 1din 9
i/Ne23-1-1298-17082015 Meno Ne 1-135/15 ONPEAEIEHHE imeem saxona 14 cenra6pa 2015 roaa m.Kompat Cyn Kompat p coctane: Tipencenatenscrayioutero, cyneu — TyGenko C.A. Tipu cexperape Kapauasi 10. c yuactuem: npoxypopa Konua ®.JJ. agboxara nogcyauMoro Buxout A. noacyaumoro Croaunorno HLH. nlorepnesureli Kunaast AD. allpokata norepnesueli Beio Hi. paceMoTpes B OTKpsITOM cyzeSHOM 3acenaHHH B XoZe rlogroToBHTeNbHOH uacTH yronosHoro gena No1-135/15 no o6sunenmwo Crosnuorno HuKonaa Huxosaesuya B cosepuienun mpectynenua npenycmorpenuoro ct.188 4,(2) me) YK PM, xoxataiictso mpoxypopa mpoxypatypst myx.Kompar Koma ©.Jl. 0 NpoieHHH B OTHOUIeHHH orcyzHMoro CTosHMorIo Huxonas Huxomaesia, Mepsi mpecevensa B BHe MpeaRapHTenbioro apecta cpoxom Ha 90 cyToK, 4 aaapneHHe agpokata Bukon A. 06 w3MeHeHMM MepsI MpecedeHHa B OTHOMICHHH nogcyaumoro Crossmoro Haxonaa Haxosaesia c mpenbapittensHoro apecta Ha OGssaTenbeTBO O He BHIeSMe 13 MeCTHOCTH HAH Ha AOMAIIHBM apect, Yeranosua: 09.09.2015 roga B cya Kompar B pamkax yronosnoro nena Ne!-135/2015 no oSpnHenmo Croanvorno Huxonaa Hukonaesuia p copepulenun mpectyruenua Mpeaycmotpenoro cr.188 4.(2) ne) YK PM, noctynuso xoataiicrso npokypopa npokypatypsi myx. Kompar Kosiua J], 0 mpowiexiu B oTHOWeHHH noxcyauMoro Crosimorio Huxonas Huxonaesi4a, Mepbt npeceveHuia 8 Bue mpenBapHtensHoro apecra cpoKom Ha 90 cyTox. Yearannoe xogataiicrso npeacrasurestem rocyzapersenuoro o6puneHHa MOTHBUpOBAHO —caeayioMMH = ocHoBanuaMH: Hactosttee — xoslataiicrBo Hanpapasetca B cya Kompar 1 xogaraiictayet Ha ocHopanuu 1.16) 4.(1) ¢.52, cr. 177 4.(2), er. 185 4.(1) w ct. 186 4.3) YIIK PM ssiiectn pemenue o npoasenun MepbI MpecedeHus B BHAe NpeABapHTerbHOrO apecta, cpoKOM Ha 90 cyTOK, B oTHOWeHHH NogcyauMoro CrosHuorno Hukonan Huxosaaesuua, 03.07.1983 Toa pokueHHs, ypoxenya c. Yox-MatinaH, npoxupaiomero no ys. C. Jla30, XOsocTOro, He HMEIOUIerO THU Ha WIMBeHHH, He TpyZoyctpoeHHOro, pave He cyAMMoro, O6pa3oBaHive cpedHee, He eMyTata, He MHBaNIMa, Bilayeioulero pyccKHM. sabIKOM, TparxaatHHa PM, Koropbili Gs sanepxKaH 17 wions 2015 roga B 12:40 ¥acoB BBMAY Toro, 4TO 08.10.2014 B OTHOWeHHM To”cyaHMoro:CrosuHorno H.H. cynom Kompar 61a u36pava Mepa mpeceyenus B BHze npemBaputenbHoro apecta cpokom Ha 30 cyTox H BbIzaH opmep Ha ero apect. Cpok Mepbi mpecevenHa ncTeKaeT 15 centa6pa 2015 r. B 12.40 4acos. 1) Huxpumuunpyemoe jeanne: n. e) 4. (2) er. 188 YK PM. OGcrosTererna nena: IL centa6pa 2014r., npumepto B 21.004acos, Crosunorno Huxosali Huxonaesny, naxogscs 8 noc.Bymkak, p-Ha Kompar, PM, HanpoTus JoMoBnaeHHA, no yx.Cranunontiaa N89, ¢ Weblo XHULeHHA HMYuecTBA Apyroro Mua, romoWeN Kk vaymel no ys.Ctauumonnas, 8 Hanpassenmn ys.Kuumenckas Kunadnst Auacracum Teopruesve n, cxBaTue ee pykoli 3a ropso, MoTammn K oGoNHHe, re OBA Ha 3eMMO, MlOCAe 4eTO, MPHCTABHB HOX K ropily, Cran TpeGoBaTb ce MoGuAbHEIH TeeoH, Mone «Nokia Lumia 520», croumoctsio 2500 self, KoTopsiii Gui y rlotepnesueli B pyKax. OnHAKO, MoTepmenuias OKazala COMpoTHBNeHNe 1 crata KpHuaTs o OMOUIN, B CBAIH C Hem Croauuorsio H.H. He yulatocs sapnagers ee Tenedouom u OH yOexKaul, CKPLIBLIUCE C MecTa MpectyneHus. JakonoaaTenbuble HOPMbI, KOTOpEIe _OGocHOBEIBAIOT _pasymHocTE alepacaHust Cr. 165 4. (3) n. 2), er. 166 4. (1) 1. 2) wer. 167 4. (1) YIIK PM Kouxpermpie o6cronteawctra, — oGocHopbinalome —_pasymHocrs Npoasienua Mepsi Mpece4eHust B BHAe MpeABApHTeAbHOFO apecta: Crosmmorno HLH. 6xit sanep:xan 17.07.2015 r. a B ero OTHOUIEHHH MoxeT 6siTb u3Gpana Mepa npeceyeHMa B BHAe NPewBApHTeNbHOTO apecTa B COOTBETETSHH ¢ ‘tpeGosanuamu ct. 186 4. (3) YIIK PM. [pecrynuenne, 8 conepuenum Koroporo oSsunserca Croauvormo H.H. mpemyemarpupaet wakasaHve B BYne mHMeHHA cBoGoasi 20 10 net H OTHOCHTCA K KaTeTOPHH THKKUX MpecTyTUIeHUH, H, HeKONS HS mpenyemorpenusix 4.2 ct. 176 YIIK PM yeaonuii, 3a copepusertice Crosnuorno HI. neque 3akonom mpuMenierca Mepa TipeceseHna B BHNe NpelbapHTesbHOTO apecta HM 8 COOTBeTCTBHH Cc MoTOXKeHHAMH cT.186 YIIK PM momcyaumomy Crosumorno HH. Heo6xonumo mpogiuts Mepy mpeceyenus B BHIe npempaputersuoro apecta, Tak KaK MIpH W36paHHH HHOl MepsI npeceyeHHA OH ckpoetea OT OpraHoB yroMOBHOTO MpecteMOBAHHA, 4TO MoNTBEpxNAeTeA TeM, YTO onpenenennem cya Kompat ot 12,09.2014r. 8 oTHowennH nogcyaumoro Crosmuorno HLH. 6bita w36pana Mepa npeceveHHa B BHZe DOMaLIHeTO apecta cpokoM Ha 30 cyTox, pH 9TOM cyfOM Ha MloxcyauMoro Crosuuorsio HLH. 6si10 BOSTOXKHO OGA3ATETBCTBO He MOKHAATS CBOe MecTO >KuTembeTBA(c.YoK-MaiiaK p- a Kompar ys.C.Jlaso 272) yo ucteueHua cpoka foMallHero apecta 160 ero ugMenenna, Ogwaxo Crosnuorio HLH. Hapyuima mepy mpeceyenus 8 suze AOMAaIHEro apecTa H CKPbUICA OT OpraHOB YTOOBHOFO MpecseqOBaHHA, B CBASH C 4eM Obit OObABIEH B posBicK. 08.10.2014 r. cyueOHaR UHeTAHUMS yqoBReTBOpATA xogaraiicrso mpoxypopa 06 w3MeHeHMH noncyzuMomy CroasMorio H.H. Mepsi Mpeceuenna u Bbytana opaep Ha apect Crosauorio H.H., wa6pap B OTHOUIeHAK Croauuoro H.H. Mepy mpecesexua suze mpespaputerbuoro apecta. B xope pO3bICKHBIX MepontpHATHH nogcynuMsti Crosimorno HH. bit sageprxKan Ha Tepputopun Poceuiicko Desepauvin H okcTpanMpoBaH B PM. B orHomenun Crosnnorno H.H. cyuectByior pasyMuble 1 Heomponep2xuMBie AoKasaTeMLCTBA B COBEPUICHUH BMcHAeMOTO EMY MIPECTYIMICHUA H LaHHoe yenonHe, npenyemorpentioe ct.176 YIIK PM coGmoneno. Heomponepxumutit xapaxtep OOBHHeHHH ogTBepKNAeTCA cHeAYIOMIMMH (bakTHYecKHMH OGcTosTenBCTBAMH. (dokasarensctBaMn), a HMeHHO moKasarHem nozcyzuMoro Crosumorno HH. 1 norepresmeli Kunahasr A., pesynstaramn cyleOHO-MeMUMHCKOM 9kcrepTH3si norepnesuieit. 2) 3axounpie _ocHionanus _nonaraTe, _uTo _nogeyanMbtii Mower BOCIIpensTeTBOBAT yeTaHOB.eNMI0 HeTHHBI NO e.ry: KonkperHble apryMeHTb! ocHoBaHHii nosaratb, 4To nogcygHMbIi MorKeT BOCIIPeNATCTROBATH YCTAHOBNEHIO HCTHHBI: B nacrosujee Bpemsa y opraHa yroslosHoro mpecaemoBania ects ocHOBaHHA nosarath, “To nogeyzumetit Crosuvorno H.H. Moxet Bocnpenarcrsosats YCTAHOBJICHHIO HCTHHBI B YTOMOBHOM Mpouecce M CKPbITBCH OT OpraHOB yrosOBHOTO Tpecitenowarina, Tak Kak Mlocte coBepuleHua mpectynmenHa uv u36paHun B OTHOUIeHAM Hero MepsI mpeceyeHHa B BME AOMalUHero apecta Crosuuormo H. CKPBLICR OT OpraHoB yrosoBHoro mpecieqosanus. Kpome Toro, Haxoysich Ha cBoGore MONCyAMMEI MOET Oka3aTb MICMXHECKOe NABAeHHe Ha NOTepMeBLIYIO, TAK kak Mpectyrutenwe coRepureHo ¢ MpuMeHeHHem HacHAHA M yrpo3oi npuMeHeHua HACHIMs, ONACHOTO JIA KHSHH, 3) Mpoueccyaapupie_aeiicraua, KOTOpbIe NosJeKAT NpoBeseHMIO B_LeIAX YeTaHOBJeHHA 1aTbI cyzeGHoro 3aceqaHHA AI paccMoTpenua feta nO cymecrBy: B xoge yronosHoro mpecnenosanua Heo6xomMMo mposectu cyqeGHO- NcHXHaTpHYecKyio 9KCHepTH3y AYIA YCTaHOBMeHHx cTeIeHH ~— BMeHAeMOCTH NOACYAUMOTO, MPOBECTH O4HbIE CTABKH, OKORYHTb yroNOBHOe MpecaesoBaHHe H MpeACTaBHTh MAaTepHaNbI YOAOBHOFO seMa LIA O3HAKOMIEHHA; MPHHAB TO Tey PpellicHHe B CooTBeTCTBHH Co cT.291 YIIK PM. 4) O6s2anHocTs npHHATE BO BUUMANNeE MeHee eTporne MepsA npeceveHHa: Cr. 175 4. (3)VIIKPM Konkpetnoe oObacnenue ¢akra, novemy menee crpore mepbi npecesenus cuntatores HesdibekTHBHBIMH: O6crostenbcta, KOTOPHIe MepBOHANaNBHO NocAyKWI OCHOBAKHeM nH 3aLepkAHMA HUA, Ha aHHBITi MOMeHT #BIOTCH aKTyaIbHBIMH, BMecte c TeM, Kak 6uino yeTaHoBneHo, Haxouscb Ha cpoGone Crosuuorno HH. moxer BOCHPeMATCTBOBATE YCTAHOBIEHMIO HCTHHSI B YTONOBHOM NpOUecce, CKPEITLCA OT opraHoB yroAOBHOrO MIpecuesOBAHHA, TAK KaK TlocMe CoBepLeHA npectynmeHHA 1 u36paHHM Mepbi MIpeceeHHs B BHe AOMaluHero apecta HapyimMn H36paHHY Mepy MpeceveHua M CKPBLICA, YTO CBHNETeEMBCTBYeT, YTO OH CKPOeTcd OT OpraHoB YroNOBHOrO MpecnemoRaHHa ¢ UeNbIO W30eKATE HaKa3aHHa. CrosHuorno H.H. HAXOMACh HA CROGOLE, MOXKET OKAIATS MCHXHYECKOE AABeHHe Ha TlOTepHeBLy0 TIpH NpoBeZeHMH ONHBIX CTABOK H HHBIX JeHiCTBHM, TAK KAK MpecTymeHHe COBepUeHO Cc MIpUMeHeHHeM HaCHIIHA, ONACHOTO UIA %KUSHH. 5) 3akonnbie _HopMbI_HenpuMenenMA npesBapuTerBHOro apecta coriacHo HpHHuMny HecopasmepHocTH: Cr. 176 4. (3)YTIK PM. Tipu oGpamenun B cyst ¢ HacTosUNMM xogataiicrBOM npoKypop TaKKE yuen caeaylomime xonoauuTenbuble KpuTepuLt: 1) Xapaitep u crenens spesa, mpHunHeHHoro BMeHAeMBIM JesHHeM COBEPUIEHO THKKOE NpecTyMIeHHe, COMPHKEHHOE ¢ MIPHMeHEHHEM HACHLATNA K AMY, OaCHOTO AAI KHBHH, 2) JImunocts nogcyzuMoro - He uMeeT cembu, paHee K yronosHol oTBeTCTREHHOCTH He IpUBIeKAICA. 3) Ero sospacr u cocrossue soposbs - tpe6yerea npopeenue cyne6Ho TICHXHATpHYeCKoH 9KCHepTHBBI B YcNOBUAX cTAMOHapa; 4) Poxero saxsTuit - ocbunnaasio He TpyaoycrpoeH; 5) Ero ceneiiioe nonoxeHue u HanHuMe WxIMBeHUeB - xorocT, Ha WKQMBeHHH JHU HET; 6) Ero umyulectaennoe nostoxenne - nantible oreyteTBy!oT; 7) Hanuune y Hero noctosHoro MecTa :kWTenBCTBa - He uMeeT TocTosHHoro Mecra 2kHTemBCTRA Ha TeppuTopun PM; 8) Apyrue cymecrsenusie ocrostensersa - He uMeeTes. Korkpetisie oGctosTesbetsa jena Tipit olleHKe MpHHLIa HecopasMepHocTH: coBepuleHo THKKOe MPCTYTMIeHHe ¢ YrpO3O!i MPHMeHEHMA HaCHAMA, OTIAcHOrO AU RUSH, 6) Aspoxar noaeyaumoro: Vs6panuetii samurauk no aeay: aqoxar, nonyuenneiii 8 npouece - Buxon Aumpei. Kpome Toro, 14.09.2015rona 8 xoze ocyulectBieHHs NoZroTOBKH AaHHoro yroaosHoro sera K cyeOHoMy paxGupateaLeTBy octynuso 3asBTeHHe alBoKaTa Buxon A. 06 H2MeHeHHH Mepbl mMpeceveHHa B OTHOMeHHH moxecyaNMorO Crommorno Huxosaa Huxonaesiua c mpeqpapHTerbioro apecta Ha o6a3aTemBCTBO © He Bble3ze 13 MeCTHOCTH HuIM Ha JoMaMIHHii apect. B cyneGvom 3aceaanun cTopona rocyaapcersenHoro oGBHHEHHS B Me Mpoxypopa mpoxypatypi M.Kompat Koua ®. JI, romHoctsio mosteprxasia TofaHHoe xomataiicTBo 0 npoaiennn B oTHoeHHH Croanuorno Huxoaaa Hukonaesnua Mepsl HipeceveHua B BHe MpeaBapuTembHoro apecta cpoKom Ha 90 cyTOK, cumTas 3aaBeHHe ayjBoKaTa Buxon A. He oOocHoBaHHBIM M Mogse7KallHM yaloBieTBOPeHHiO. B cyse6uom 3aceaanun notepnesman Kusadati A. u agpoxat Beio 1. TosepkAH NoLAHHOe MPOKypopom XomaTaiicTBO H MpOCHAH ero yZOBeTBOPHTS, OTKIOHHB 3AABIEHHe 3aLMTHHKa Mo~cyAMMoro. B cyae6uom 3aceaanum cropona 3auuTEl B anue agsoKata BuKos A. Npocusa OTKAOHHTb xXoRaTaHcTBO NPoKypopa Kak HeOGOCHOBAHHOe, H3MeHHB Mepy colepxkaHHa nol cTpaxKei B OTHOWeHHM nomcynHMoro CrosHMorio HuKonas Hukonaesu4a Ha OGs3aTeIbCTBO 0 He BbIe3fe H3 MeCTHOCTH HJM Ha JoMalHuii apect. B cyge6nom 3aceaaunu noacyaumeti Cromuuorao H.H. nosxoctsic ToMepxKal AOBOALI CBOeTO alBOKATA. Paccmorpes xogataiicrso npoxypopa, 3asBsenne alpoxara BuKos A., BBICYIAB OBO! NPOKypopa, noTepneBuieli ee MpenctaBatens anBoxata Bei H., TlomcyaMMoro ero mpencrasutena ampoxara BuKon A., B COBOKYMHOCTH c TpeqCTAaBNeNHBIMH MaTepHasiaMM yrosloBHOTO ea, cyneGHad MHCTAHLMA NPHXOAMT K BbIBOAY, 4TO XosaTalicTBO NpoKypopa O NposNeHHH B OTHOMIEHHH NoACyAMMOrO Crosuvorso H.H. Mepsi npeceveHia 8 Bie MpemBapHTesbHOrO apecta cpoKOM Ha 90 cyToK, sBAseTcH He OOOCHOBAHHBIM H He NosMMExKaluM yrOBTeTBOpeHHIO. B AaHHOM KOHTeKcTe CUWTAd 3aNB/eHHe aBOKATa TMogcyAMMoro YacTH4UHO OGOCHOBAHHBIM, Cy HaXOMHT Mepy MpeceveHHa B BAe NOMALIHeTO apecta, MpHemiemol HW gocTaTowHol ana oGecnevenHa HOpMambHOro xona cyseOHOro PaccileAOBAHHA, M0 CAEAYIOILMM MpaBOBbIM OCHOBAHHAM. Obeyoxdan Haxmuueckyio cmopony dea, cyeOHAs HHCTARLUNA OTMeuaer, ro 11.09.2014 roga OYTI HIT Kompat 6si1o Hayato yronotice npecnenozanue 10 yrosiosHomy gery No2014190485 no oxementam npectynenus mpeayemorpenHoro cr.188 4.(2) ne) YVKPM. —(u1..5) 12.09.2014 rona rp-ny Crosumorno H.H. 6p110 npexbaBneHo oOBHHeEHHe B cosepuleHHH mpectynenns, npeayemotpenoro cr.188 4.(2) me) YK PM. (1.2.6) Onpenenenuem cya Kompar or 12.09.2014roza 8 orHomiennu o6puasemoro Crosnuorno H.H. Gsuia v36paHa Mepa npeceveHHa B Bue MoMallHero apecta cpoxom Ha 30 cyToK c BOsTOxKeHHeM Ha OOBHHeMOrO psa OOs3aTeRBCTB, OAHAKO Crosuvorno H.H. Hapyuima Mepy npeceyenus B BME LOMalLIHero apecra M CKpBIICH of opratios yronoBoro npecaeqoBaHna, B CBA3H C_YeM Obi OOBABIEH B POsKICK. 08.10.2014 r. noncynuMsrit Croanuorno H.H. 6511 sanepxan Ha TepputopHi Poceuiickoii Penepayma u aketparuposan B PM, rye B oTHoMeHMM Hero Osim cocTabileH NpoToKom 3agepxanna oT 17.07.2015 roma. (a1.0. 260 ) OGcysicdan__nonovicenun___deitcmeyiowezo __mescdynapodnozo _u HaUnOnAreHOz0 3aKOHOdAMerLCMea (HOPMBI TIPaBa, NOMMEKALIe MIpuMeHeHHiO B JaHHOM Jere), cyneGHas HUCTAHLA OTMedaeT creAyIOUIee. Crates 24 Pexomenaaunu Conera Esportsi 0 pom mpoxypopa 8 cucteme YrONOBHOTO NpaBocyAHA 3akperieT OOA3ATEABCTBO MPOKYPOpOB, MPH BLINONHEHHH CBOHX OGs3aHHOCTeH, BHINOTHATS CBOM bYHKUAH CHpaBesLIMBO, GecnpuctpactHo H OObeKTHBHO, YBaxaTh H 3aLNMUlaTb pasa YenoBeKa, Kak ykasaHHO B EKITY, oGecneunBats, YTOGEI CHCTeMa YroTOBHOTO MpaBocyAHA (yYHKUMOHMpoBana TaK 6sICTPO, KaK 3TO BOMOXHO. B coorserersan c m1) cr.5 Esponeiicxoi Kousenuua o samme npap uenoseka HM OCHOBHBIX cBOGos, Kaxabi MMeeT mpaso Ha cBoOony Mm AITHYI0 HenpukocHosenHocrs. Hukro He MoxeT OBITb THIeH cBOGOLBI HHa¥e, Kak B TOPAULKe, YCTAHOBNeHHOM 3aKOHOM. B cuny tpeGosanuit 1.1) cr.6 Esporeiicxoii Kowpexunn o saure pap MemoBeKa H OCHOBHEIX CBOSOL, KaXKIBIH HMeeT MpaBo TPH paceMoTpeHUH mo60ro yronopHoro O6BHHeHHA, mpexbaBneHHioro eMYy, Ha cnpaBegsuBoe nyOnM4Hoe pasOupatenserso s1e7a B pasyMubili cpoK He3aBHCHMBIM H GecnpHCTpacTHBIM cyZOM. Coraacho tpeGopanuii cr.7 -4.4.(1),(5) YIIK PM, —_yronosHoe cysonpousBoCTBO OcyMecTAAAeTCA B CTPOTOM COOTBETCTBHK ¢ OOUIeNPHSHAHHIMH TIpHHUWNAMH H HOpMaMM MexkXyHAapozHOrO MpaBa, MexIyHapoAHBIMH oroBopaMm, molt 3 cTopoH KoTopbix ssasetca PecnyGnuxa Mosgosa, nonoxenuamu Koxetatyuuu Pecny6nuk Morsosa 4 yroa0BHo-npoueccyanbHoro KoueKca, B coorserersuu co ct.175 4.4.(1-2) YIIK PM, Mepamu mpecesenna apisiores MPHHYANTeTbHBIe Mepbl, NpHMeHAeMBIe K mlOMO3peBaeMOMy, OGBUHSeMoMy, TloacyAMMoMy 1 MIpemoTBpaulenMa coBepmleHUA © HM ~—_ompeylesleHHBIx OTpHUATeNbHBIX selicTBHHi B Xome yronoBHOrO cyfoMpousBoseTBa MAH Mp oSecnevennn ncnomHeHHa npurosopa. Mepst npeceuenwa Hanpapiens! Ha oGecneyenue Haanexamero xona YroTOBHOTO cyZONpowsBoscTBa IH BOCTIpenATeTBOBAHHe —YKPBIBATeMBCTRA Togo3pepaemoro, O6BHHAeMOrO, HOzCyAMMOro OT YronoBHOrO MpecnenoBaHls HIM cyaa, Ha TO, YTOOEI ykasANHBIe THA He MOMeIAN YcTAHOBeHMIO HCTHHEI, a TaKKe Ha oOecneveHHe cyfeOHOi HHCTaHuMeli McrlomHeHHA NpuroBopa. Cornacuo ct.188 4.(7) YK PM, B cayyae HecoGmogeHua noncyaMMBIM orpanuuernii u oOn3aHHocteli, ycraHosneHHbrx cyneOHoli MHcTaHUMell, NomauHHit apect MoxKeT ObITh 3aMeHEH Ha MpeABApHTeNbHBIM apect cyzeGHOM MACTARUMeH To cBoeli MHUUIMaTHBe WITH TIO XogaraiieTBY MpoKypopa. B coorserersun co cr.195 4.(1) YIIK PM, cyne6nas macranuna ormexaer, TO Kak MIpHMeHeHMe Mep mpeceyenHs, Tak H 3aMeHA TAKMX Mep, B TOM HHCHe Ha Gonee ctporve MepsI mpecevenua, somAHBI OcyllecTBNATECA B CTpOrOM COOTRETCTEUH C TPeOOBAHMAMM 3AKOHONATENBCTBA H TIPH HAIHYHH AOCTATOUHBIX 1 YOenuTeNbHLIX NOKA3ATeNCTR AWK 3TOrO. Ha Hefonyctamocrs HeoGocHoBanioro collepxKaHHa IM TOM cTpaxKeti ykasano WB mint. 6-7, 30, 62 Hoctaronnenus FLrenyma Batcurel Cye6Hoi PM 3a Nel or 15.04.2013 roma «O npumenenun cyneOHbimH MHCTAHLMAME HeKOTOpLIX TOAOKeHHH yrosnoBHO-MpoueccyatbHOrO 3aKOHOMATeMCTB —MIpesBAapHTeNBHOM apecte H OMaulHeM apecTen. C yseTom aBittensi0xKeHHoro, 3y¥ax MoRONEI _pacemarpuBaemoro xomaraiictsa cTOpoHbi rocygapcTBeHHoro oOsHHeHHA oT 09.09.201Sroma, cym CHHTaeT HEOGXOAUMBIM OTMeTHTS, 4TO comepKaHHe mpeabIAyUNX xonaTalicTs OTHOCHTENBHO COepKAHHA MOM crpaxell MOAcyAMMOFO Ha cTagHH yronoBHOro TpecnegosaHia sABAaOTCR MAeHTHUNBIMH. B MX cConepxaHHH oTcyrcTByeT MeMOHCTpAUA CTOPOHB! rocyfapeTBeHHOrO OGBHHeHUS «ocoGorO ycepaHAy B Tipouecce YctaHOBMeHHiA CYMIECTRORAHHA| MOTHBOB, OKA3bIBAIOLINX, 470 noacyaumeii Crosiuorno H. monsepxex pHcky, mpepsimaiourero paMKH ero npaga Ha cnoGony. B gaHHoM KOHTeKcTe cilelyeT OTMeTHTS, 4TO cysbeli mo yronoBHOMy Mpecnegopanmio ( B Xoje YyFoNOBHOTO MpectenoBaHMa ) B BBIHeCeHHBIX HM onpegenennsx eogHoKpaTHo Obi OGpauleHO BHMMaHMe Ha ykasantbie oScrosTeTscTBa, OAHAKO CTOpoHO!i rocyzapcTseHHOro OGBHHEHHA Ha TpoTHKEHUN BCerO BPEMEHH MpOAMeHNA comepxAHHA NoAcyAMMOrO Nox cTpaxei TAKHX moKasaTeSCTB TAK NpelcTaBTeHO H He GELIO. OuleHupas MOTHBEI M NpaBoBble OCHOBAHHA BHeCeHHOrO MpoKypopom XonatalicTBa, aHaNM3Mpysi OKa3aTeNbcTBa, MpeCTaBNeHHBIe MpoKypopoM B cyneGHoI0 HHCTaHIMO B OGOCHOBAHHe HeOGXOAMMOCTH mMpomTeHUA MepBI npecedenua B OTHOUIeHAH nogcyaumoro Crosnuorno H.H., cymeOHaa uncTaHuHs oTMeHaer, 470 CTOpOHOli rocynapeTReHHOrO OGBHHEHHR He TIpeacTaBNeHO cymy Haienalux akTHYecKHX AaHHBIX Toro, 4TO MogcyAUMBIA paHee Hapymina yeraHoBneHHoe cys1OM OGA2aTeLCTBO He OOULATECs c MIOGKIMH JIMUAMH, KOTOPEIC TIpAMO HIM KOCREHHO HMeIOT OTHOMIeHHe K PAaccMaTpHBAeMOMY YTONOBHOMY Aealy, 3a HCKMOYeHHeM 3aIUTHUKa H OpraHa yronoBHOrO MpectenoBaHHs. Kpome Toro, cropouioii rocysaperBenHoro OGaHHeHHA He mpemctasmeHo Hasexamx akTHYECKHX JAHHBIX TOTO, TO MONCYAUMBIM KaK CaM JIHUHO, TAK 1 10 cpevcTROM HHBIX NHL MbITa‘Ica BosLeFICTBOBATS Ha OTepreBIyIO KAKUM TO O6pasom ¢ Webi H3MeHeHUA e10 CBOUX NOKA2aHHii. B AaHHOM KOHTeKCTe cys OTMeyaeT, ITO KaK MCXOAHT 13 AoBO08 ToTepnesme Kwame A., Ha cTaMH yroxoBHoro Tpecnenosanns c Heli owarca He noweyzuUMeKi, a rp-¥ Crosuorio Mean, TO ects ABoLOponHsii Gpat OGBMHXIeMOTO H APYTHE POACTBEHHHKH MONCyAUMOTO, HO HH CaM noacyamMeti. Tiponomkas oleHHBATh MOTHBBI CTOpOHEI OOBHHEHKA HBTOKeHHDIE B oGocHoBarHe paccMarpuBaemoro XogaraiicTRa, cy OTMewaeT, 4TO —naHHOli cTopoHioli npouecca akueHTHpoBaio BHUMaHHe Ha ToM, uto Crosuuormo H.H. HapylHA Mepy MpecedeHHa B BMAe AOMALIHeTO apecta M CKpbUICR OT OpraHoB yronosHoro npecteNOBaHHA, BCBASH ¢ Hem GBI OGbABLIEH B posbick 08.10.2014r. aB Xoje posKIcKHLIX MeponpusTHit noacyauMeili Croannorso FLH. Obi sazepxan Ha ‘Tepputopun Poccuiickoli Denepauun H 9KcTparMpoBaH BPM. B gaHiiom kourexcte cy oTMeyaeT, uTO B cooTReTCTRHH ¢ M1) cr.5 Exponelickoit Konsexunn 0 3ailute mpap venoseka M OcHOBHEIX CBOGOA, KAXUbIi HMeeT npao Ha cBOGOAY H TMYHYIO HempuKocHoBeHHocTs. Huxto He MoxeT GEITE JIMUIeH CBOGOABI HHAYe, Kak B MOpsAKe, YCTAHOBJIEHHOM 3aKOHOM, MOITOMY 9TH OOcTOsTeNBCTBA He MOFYT CJYXKHTb BeCKHM OCHOBAHHeEM Ia cTOTB NposowKHTeTbHOTO comepyarHA MloAcyAHMOrO Nog cTpaxkelt. B coorserersuu co cr.5 4.(4) EKITY, ompoe 3akonnocra conepxKaHHa muna TOA ctpaxeii aBAReTCA AINTEAHBIM BO BPeMeHH, MPH TOM, 4TO apecr KOTOpBIi B CaMOM Hayalle, MOxKeT ObITb 3AKOHHBIM, BIOCACACTBAM MO%KET CTATE H€3aKOHHBIM B CHIY H3MeHeHHs OGCTOSTENBCTB HH HOBBIX YIIMK, OSTOMY cy. 3aBepseT 0 CHOC TOTOBHOCTH TlepeCMATPHBATh B CPOYHOM MoOpsAKe BONPOCKI O TOM, HacKOTBKO ompapiaH apecT Noscymymoro, win ero HaxoxmeHHe nom MNO Mepolt npeceyenns. TIpumep Toro, 470 3akmou¥eHMe nom ctpaxy mula coBepmmMButero TIpecTyMIeHHe ABIAETCA HeMpeMeHHBIM YCIIOBHEM JLIK 3AKOHHOCTH CosepxKAaHHA ero TOA CTpaxkeii, HO MO NpoulecrauH onpeneneHHoro BpemeHu mepectaer wMeTs peulaioulee 3HaveHHe, YeTKO OTpaxeH B MocTaHoBAeHHax ExponelicKoro cysa, a HMeHHO 110 zeny «XyA06uH nporne Poccuu», rae 4310%KEHO, 4TO MUO KOTOPOMY NPeRbABEHO OOBHHCHHE B COBEPUIEHAM NpecTyMeHHA ROMKHO GbITS HeMemTeHHO ocBoGoxKeHO 0 cya ec TONBKO OpraHbI OcyMapcTBeHHO! BracTH He MpencraBsT COOTBETCTBYIOUUX H OTHOCAMINXCS K HEY MPHYKH OBOCHOBEIBAIOMIUX MpomIEHHe cpoka cogep:kaHua lon crpaxeii. Take Esponeiicknii cyn B noctaxonnenun or 08.06.2006roza rio wey «Kapueranosa npotus Poccum nogiepxHyn 0 Tom, yTo 1.3) ct.5 KoHBeHuHH OGasbIBAeT TOCyNApeTBeHHbIe OpralbI PaCcMOTpeTs BOSMOXKHOCTS TIpHMereHAT QJIbTepHATHBHBIX Mep OGecrieyeHHA BKM MOcyMMMorO B cy Mp pewenny BOTIPOCA O TOM OCBOGOAMTS JIH eFO H3 3alla Ca WIH OCTABHTS Mon cTparxeli. B coorserersum c mpaktuxoii Esponelickoro Cyna, Cyne6uas mctannns cuWTaeT, YTO BeposTHOCT® Toro, ¥TO OGBHHAeMBIl CKpoeTcA HIM TIpomoMKUT MpecTYNHY!0 JEATEMBHOCTS LONMKHA PaccMATPHBATBCA CO CCBLIKO! Ha PAX APYTHX (axtos, KoTOpble MOryT HosTsepaNTS HaNHYHe pHCKa noSera WH NOBTopHOrO copepluenua npectynenna. Tak 0 HaMepeHMH CKpbITBCA MOryT CBHATENBCTBOBATS TAKHe NAHHEIe, KaK: - CBHJeTeIBCKHe TOKa3aHHs; - HaNH4ve Ha WMa nMogcyaMMoro mpHobpeTeHHBIX Npoesmubix GuaeToR 3a rpaHMuy; - cHATHA c perHcTpalluoHHOTO yueTa ¢ MecTa OKHTENGCTB; - CHATHA © BOHHCKOTO y'eTA; - OTCYTCTBHE CBASH Mey OOBHTAeMBIM 4 ctpaHoi mpeObiBaHHa B JaHHOM cny4ae Pecny6mmKoii Mongopa, uv upyrue (baktH4eckwe jaHHble, OHAKO KAKHX-AMGO OKasaTeTBCTB OOOCHOBBIBAIOLINX BBILEHBIOKEHHOe CTOPOHOH OOBHHEHHA He MpemcTABseHo, a cOOTBETCTBeHHO cuntars, uro Crosuuorno H.H. ckpoetca of cya, He MMelOTCA 3aKOHHBIX ocHosannii. Kak mp w3GpanH Mepsi mpeceyenis, Tak H npH ee mposteHun cTopoxa TocynapeTBeHHOro OOBHHHHA B HACTH XapakTepH3YIOWUX AMYHOCTS OOBHHKeMOrO AOBOLOB, HE MIpeACTABHJAa CBOHX JOBOLOB H OUEHKY OTHOCHTESIbHO HeBO3MOxKHOCTH NpHMenenua Goslee MarkOH Mepbl npeceyeHHa HexKeNH MpeqBapuTenbuBili apect, Torna kak 4.(3) ct.175 YIIK PM o6ssmisaet npu w36panun Mepsi npeceyenua 1 TH ce MpogeHHH HEOGXONMMOCTS YYTEHHA WIM HCIOYeHHA MeHee CypOBbIX Mep mpecevenna. Tloawepxupax oco6eHHocts mpanoii cHctemst P.M. B KoTopoli mpabopas ksanngukaliad akt0R HW mpenBsBeHHe OOBUHeHHA Onpenensetcs npoKypopom, Esponelicxuii cy ormeyaet, To THKECTS MpexbaBTeHHOTO OGBHHEHHs (TO MMeeT MeCTO B JaHHOM cmY¥ae) HE MO%KET CHYKUT eAMHCTBEHHBIM OCHOBAHHeEM Is onpapaaHus AIHTeMbHOCTA CpoKa COMePIKAKHA Non cTpaxKeli B paMKax 136paHHOH Mepbi mpeceveHHa, KaK TIpenBapHTeNbHOTO apecta, TOSTOMY CCBUIKH OOBHHEHHA Ha TweCTh MpeNbABTeHHOTO OOBHHeHHA, KaK Ha peulaioulee OCHOBaHKe mpH TpoAeHUH cpoKa coLepKakiuA Nok cTpaxell He UMeIOT 3HAYeHHA IIa OUeHKH onacoctH Toro, 4TO MOACYANMBI cKpoeTcA OT cya, AMGO NPoAOWKUT 3aHUMATECA IPectyNHOHi ZeATeNBHOCTHIO, NOSTOMY B LaHHOM KOHKpeTHOM cily4ae cya cuHTaeT, 4TO QA Mpognenus MoyicynMMoMy cpoKa mMpeiBapHTenbHoro apecta Ha ganpaumpaembie TIpoKypopom 90 cyTOK, y cya He MIMeIOTCH 3aKOHHBIX ocHoBaHuil. TIponomsas oGocHosbsaTs BbIHOCHMOe peuleHMe mo pacemaTpHBaemMomMy XoataiicTay CTOpoHBI OGBHHeHHA, H 3aKBNeHMIO SALTS cya aKWeHTHpyeT cpoe BHUMaHHe Ha TOM, 4TO 110 MPOWecTBHH ANHTeENbHOTO NepHoma BpEMeHH, OTCYTCTBHe HAVUMATHRBI 1 HasIEKaMUX @akTHYeCKAX LaHHBIX OOBHHEHHA, NOATBEprLAIOULHX MOTHBBI, JOKa3bIBaIOWX, YTO MoscyLMMBIii CrosHuorno H. nowBepxkeH PHCKy, Tpeppiuaioutero pak ero mpapa Ha cBOGomy, HMeIOT MecTO 0 HacTosultero Bpemen, Torna Kak B cooTBeTCTBHH co cr.5 4.(3) Eponeiicxoli Korpenunu, mHU0, OOBHHAeMOe B COBEPIIEKMH MIpecTYNHeHUA NOMKHO GbITh Bcera OCBOGOK EHO B paMkax Mpotiecca, 3a HCKMOYEHHEM CiyYas, KOrMa FOCYApPCTBO MOXET DOKAzaTB, 4TO cyMeCTBYIOT PeNeBAHTHDIe HM OCTATOUHBIe MOTHBBI, OMpaBAbIBAlOUMMe janbHeliulee comepxKaHve nomcyAMMoro TON cTparKeli, KoTOpOe He3aBHCHMO OT AUMTeABHOCTH cpoka JOWKHO ObITs yOequTeNbHEIM, a MpesyMmiua Beerta jOMKHa OBITS TOAKOBaHa B TOMY OCBOOOKACHHA, 4TO He UMeeT MecTO B AaHHOM cryuae. Cratséit 185 YIIK PM npenycmorpeno, sTo npeasapatesbHBIi apecr MoxeT 6viTs npuMenéu B cayyasx mpemycMoTpeHHEIx craTbéi 176 YIIK PM, a TakKe ecriH, ToncyuMbit He HMeeT TlOCTOmHHOr MecTa 2%MTenbeTBA Ha TeppuTopHH PM, He yeraHoBneHa ero JMMHOCTS, HapyllHT ycnoBHs patee H3OPAHHBIX B OTHOUIeHH Hero Mep ripeceyeHua. Kpome Toro, cyae6Haa npaxtaka EKITY paspaGorana versipe rasHsix MOTHBa, TIpHMeHHMBIe IA ONpABNAHHA COAepKAHHA MUA MOA cTpaxel so BIHeCeHHA TIpuroBopa: = pHCk Toro, 4TO TOACYZHMBIIi He ABUTeA Hepen cyAoM; = puck Toro, 410 B cayyae ocBOSOXKTEHHA OGBHHAeMBI npennpuMer Mepst, Hanocstuue yulepS ocymIecTBeHMiO Mpanocy sus; - puck TOFO, 4TO NOACyAUMBIi CoRePLINT HHBIe IpectyneHHA; - plick Toro, TO MOACyAUMBIIi HapyLINT OGiecTBEHHEI: NOpAIOK; Kak vcxomuT H3 MaTepHanos jena auunocTs TomeygMMoro CrosHorio H. yetaHionieHia, UMeeT MocTosHHoe MecTo xHTeNbeTBA Ha TeppHTopuH PM (s1.2.18), patie He cyquM (1.2.20), TO MecTy 2KHTeNKCTBA XapakTepH3yeTcA NONOAHTENBHO (2.2.96), coctour Ha JI yuere y. spaia ncuxuarpa.(s1..1. 90) TpHHuMaa Bo BHMMAHHe BLILIeH3/1O>KeHHOe, C YYETOM OTCYTCTBHA OcHOBAHHIL JIA IPOAMeHHA cpoKa conepxaHHa TogcyauMOTO CrosHHorno HLH. nog erpaxkelt, 4 OTCYTCTBHA KaKHX HGO OrpanMueHuit npenyemotpenubx ct.188YTIKPM, cyaeGHas HHCTaHMs TOMB3YSCb CBOMM MpaBOM 3aMCHHTh MpexBapHTerbHBIH apect Ha OMALIHHi apect, BpeMeHHoe OcBOGoxKLeHHe Non cymeOHEI KOHTpoM WI BpeMeHHoe ocBOGOAeHHe TOA 3ailor, 4TO gakperuieHo B cT.186 ¥.(7) YIIK PM, NPHXOAUT K BBIBOAY O YACTHYHOH OGOCHOBAHHOCTH AOBOLOB ALLTEL TOscyAHMOrO i HeOGXO_MMOCTH WIMeHeHHs MepsI TIpece¥eHHA B OTHOUIeHHH 8 noscynmmoro Croasnorio HH. ¢ mpeasaputenbHoro apecta Ha somaumnuii apect, OcBOGOsIMB eFO U3 No CTpALKM B3alIe CYs1a, BOOxUB Ha MOAcyANMOTO pall orpannsennit W oGszareavers. Ha ocuonannn HanoreHHoro, pykonoaetaysich et.ct. 175, 176, 188, 307, 308 YIIKPM, cya onpeaeana: Xoxataiicrso mpokypopa mpoxypatyps! .Kompar Konua ®.JL. o mpontennn 8 OTHOUIEHHH nloseyauMoro CrosuMorio Huxonaa Hukoaaesusa Mepsi npeceyenus B Bue mpemBapHTerbHOrO apecta cpoKoM Ha 90 cyTOK, OTKIOHHTS — KaK HeoGocHopannioe. Sanpaenue anpoKara Bukon A. 06 u3sMeHeHHH MepsI mpeceyeHHa B OTHOMIEHHH noncyaumoro CrosnHorio Hukonas Hukosaesnua c mpeqsapurensHoro apecta Ha oGssaTeMbcTBO O He sBBlezte 3 MeCTHOCTH HTM Ha — OMALIHMl apecr, yaoBaeTRopHTs yacTHMHO Usmenuts 8 otHoutennm nogcyzuMoro Croaxvorto Hukonaa Huxoraesuva 03.07.1983roaa poxaenns, w/x 0991910190933, npoxnBaiouero no aapecy: ¢.YoK- Majizan Komparekoro paiiona, ys.CJlaxe, 272, rpaxsmaumua PM, mepy Npecevenus, ¢ npezBapHTenbHOrO apecta Ha JOMAIHUM apect, ycTaHOBUB cpoK B 30cyToK, (To ecrs 20 15.10.201Sroua 12.40uacos), ocBoGonHs ero u3 NoA crpaxcH B jane cya, COMpoBoaHB AaHHylo Mepy mpeceyema Bosi0xKeHHeM Ha noaeyaumoro Crosumorao H.H. caeayromux orpanusenuil: 1) sanper Bbixoza 13 aH; 2) orpanwenne tenedonubix meperopopos, noayyenua Mm oTmpassienus KOPPeCHlOHEHLMH H HcTIONb30BAHHA ApyTUX cpelcTs cBssH; 3) sanper oGmarses c onpereneHHbIMH LAMM H MPHHUMATs Koro-1H60 B cBOEM KUL; 1H Bosoxennem Ha HoacyauMoro Cromuuorso H.H. oGasaunocreit; 1) Tloasepxupars B paGo¥em cocrosHuM siekrpouHsle cpexcTBa KOHTpoAA NocTOsHHO HOCHTS Hx IIpH ceOe; 2) Orscuars Ha CHTHAJIBI KOHTPOMA MH HYHO ABIATECA B Cy NPH KAKIIOM BEI30Be; 3) Hansop 3a HetlonveHem JoMallHero apecta BOITOKHTS Ha praH HajleneHHbIli TaKHMM HOAHOMOUHAMH, a HMeHHO Ha PKII Kompar; Tpeaynpeauts noaeyawmoro Crosuuorao HLH. 0 tom, 470 8 cayyae He coGmoneHNA HM YKa3aHHbIX OrpaHHYeHHi uM OGa3aHHOCTeil, ycTaHoBneHHEIX cyaeGHoi wHcTaHunell, noMaMHUH apect Moxer GObiTS 3aMeHeH Ha MpenwaputenbHbii apect cyneGHoli MHCTaHLMel mo cBOei HHUNMATHBe WAM MO xogaraliersy npoxypopa. Onperenenne o6scagppannio He Hogaexur. Cyaba cya Komp; Konus nepiia, Cynes cyna Komp TyGenko C.A. Ty6enxo C.A.