h1 in h2 in h3 in h1 m h2 m h3 m

2 3.333333E-05 1.39 0.55 1 0.035306 0.01397 0.0254

4 6.666667E-05 2.7 1.06 3.4 0.06858 0.026924 0.08636
6 0.0001 6.1 2.33 3.32 0.15494 0.059182 0.084328
8 0.0001333333 9.62 3.65 5.34 0.244348 0.09271 0.135636
10 0.0001666667 19.31 8.05 8.89 0.490474 0.20447 0.225806
12 0.0002 25.36 9.34 11.45 0.644144 0.237236 0.29083
14 0.0002333333 28.53 11.49 17.18 0.724662 0.291846 0.436372
16 0.0002666667 35.57 16.01 21.13 0.903478 0.406654 0.536702
18 0.0003 44.03 20.27 32.36 1.118362 0.514858 0.821944
20 0.0003333333 54.33 25.9 33.17 1.379982 0.65786 0.842518
22 0.0003666667 63.46 31.76 39.81 1.611884 0.806704 1.011174
24 0.0004 75.68 38.4 55.1 1.922272 0.97536 1.39954

l 0.94 psi1 0.3 f1exp f1teo f2exp

D 0.05 psi2 1 6.47227552 2.36561257 14.5975423
Dp1 0.01 psi3 1 3.14301149 2.05780629 7.03336127
Dp2 0.0171 3.1559457 1.95520419 6.87116636
Dp3 0.0137 2.79960838 1.90390314 6.05466242
E1 0.75 3.59653641 1.87312251 8.54619747
E2 0.75 3.28011405 1.8526021 6.88591135
E3 0.56 2.71111467 1.83794465 6.22359037
2.58789164 1.82695157 6.63939351
2.53107995 1.8184014 6.64179981
2.52977503 1.81156126 6.87411536
2.44206317 1.80596478 6.96646044
2.44715133 1.80130105 7.07759625
vel RE1 RE2 RE3 h1 lam h1 tur h1 ergun h2 lam
0.01697653 243.65974 1388.86052 632.223189 0.00335814 0.00954618 0.01290432 0.00010336
0.03395305 487.31948 2777.72104 1264.44638 0.00671628 0.03818472 0.044901 0.00020672
0.05092958 730.97922 4166.58156 1896.66957 0.01007442 0.08591561 0.09599003 0.00031008
0.06790611 974.63896 5555.44207 2528.89276 0.01343257 0.15273886 0.16617143 0.00041344
0.08488264 1218.2987 6944.30259 3161.11595 0.01679071 0.23865447 0.25544518 0.0005168
0.10185916 1461.95844 8333.16311 3793.33914 0.02014885 0.34366244 0.36381129 0.00062016
0.11883569 1705.61818 9722.02363 4425.56232 0.02350699 0.46776277 0.49126976 0.00072351
0.13581222 1949.27792 11110.8841 5057.78551 0.02686513 0.61095545 0.63782058 0.00082687
0.15278875 2192.93766 12499.7447 5690.0087 0.03022327 0.77324049 0.80346377 0.00093023
0.16976527 2436.5974 13888.6052 6322.23189 0.03358142 0.95461789 0.98819931 0.00103359
0.1867418 2680.25714 15277.4657 6954.45508 0.03693956 1.15508765 1.1920272 0.00113695
0.20371833 2923.91688 16666.3262 7586.67827 0.0402977 1.37464976 1.41494746 0.00124031

f2 teo f3exp f3teo

1.85800221 5.02931841 1.98725799
1.8040011 4.27492064 1.86862899
1.78600074 1.85525968 1.829086
1.77700055 1.67853502 1.8093145
1.77160044 1.78842562 1.7974516
1.76800037 1.59960266 1.789543
1.76542889 1.76334062 1.783894
1.76350028 1.6604609 1.77965725
1.76200025 2.00924375 1.776362
1.76080022 1.66822492 1.7737258
1.75981838 1.65468732 1.77156891
1.75900018 1.92441281 1.7697715
h2 tur h2 ergun h3 lam h3 tur h3 ergun
0.00167477 0.00177813 0.00119824 0.00883818 0.01003642
0.00669907 0.00690579 0.00239649 0.0353527 0.03774919
0.01507291 0.01538299 0.00359473 0.07954358 0.08313832
0.02679629 0.02720973 0.00479298 0.14141081 0.14620379
0.04186921 0.042386 0.00599122 0.22095439 0.22694562
0.06029166 0.06091181 0.00718947 0.31817433 0.32536379
0.08206364 0.08278716 0.00838771 0.43307061 0.44145832
0.10718517 0.10801204 0.00958596 0.56564325 0.5752292
0.13565623 0.13658646 0.0107842 0.71589224 0.72667644
0.16747682 0.16851042 0.01198244 0.88381758 0.89580002
0.20264696 0.20378391 0.01318069 1.06941927 1.08259996
0.24116662 0.24240694 0.01437893 1.27269731 1.28707624
 hMP1,exp hMP1,Ergun hMP2,exp hMP2,Ergun
2 0.03531 0.0129 0.01397 0.001778
4 0.06858 0.0449 0.02692 0.006906
6 0.1549 0.09599 0.05918 0.01538
8 0.2443 0.1662 0.09271 0.02721
10 0.4905 0.2554 0.2045 0.04239
12 0.6441 0.3638 0.2372 0.06091
14 0.7247 0.4913 0.2918 0.08279
16 0.9035 0.6378 0.4067 0.108
18 1.118 0.8035 0.5149 0.1366
20 1.38 0.9882 0.6579 0.1685
22 1.612 1.192 0.8067 0.2038
24 1.922 1.415 0.9754 0.2424

𝒉𝑴𝑷𝟏,𝒆𝒙𝒑 , 𝒉𝑴𝑷𝟏 ,𝑬𝒓𝒈𝒖𝒏 𝒗𝒔 𝑼𝒆𝒙 p 𝒉𝑴𝑷𝟐

1
2
0.9

𝒉𝑴𝑷𝟐,𝒆𝒙𝒑, 𝒉𝑴𝑷𝟐,𝑬𝒓𝒈𝒖𝒏 (m)

1.8
𝒉𝑴𝑷𝟏,𝒆𝒙𝒑, 𝒉𝑴𝑷𝟏,𝑬𝒓𝒈𝒖𝒏 (m)

1.6 0.8
1.4 0.7
1.2 0.6
1 hMP1,exp 0.5
hMP1,Ergun 0.4
0.8
0.6 0.3
0.4 0.2
0.2 0.1
0 0
0 5 10 15 20 25 0 5
𝑼𝒆𝒙p (L/min)
 hMP3,exp hMP3,Ergun
0.0254 0.01004 𝒉𝑴𝑷𝟑,𝒆𝒙𝒑, 𝒉𝑴𝑷𝟑 ,𝑬𝒓𝒈𝒖𝒏 𝒗𝒔 𝑼𝒆𝒙 p
0.08636 0.03775
1.4
0.08433 0.08314

𝒉𝑴𝑷𝟑,𝒆𝒙𝒑, 𝒉𝑴𝑷𝟑,𝑬𝒓𝒈𝒖𝒏 (m)

0.1356 0.1462 1.2

0.2258 0.2269 1
0.2908 0.3254 0.8 hMP3,
0.4364 0.4415 hMP3,
0.6
0.5367 0.5752
0.4
0.8219 0.7267
0.8425 0.8958 0.2
1.011 1.083 0
0 5 10 15 20 25
1.4 1.287
𝑼𝒆𝒙p (L/min)

𝒉𝑴𝑷𝟐,𝒆𝒙𝒑, 𝒉𝑴𝑷𝟐 ,𝑬𝒓𝒈𝒖𝒏 𝒗𝒔 𝑼𝒆𝒙 p

1
0.9
𝒉𝑴𝑷𝟐,𝒆𝒙𝒑, 𝒉𝑴𝑷𝟐,𝑬𝒓𝒈𝒖𝒏 (m)

0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5 hMP2,exp
hMP2,Ergun
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0 5 10 15 20 25
𝑼𝒆𝒙p (L/min)
,𝑬𝒓𝒈𝒖𝒏 𝒗𝒔 𝑼𝒆𝒙 p

hMP3,exp
hMP3,Ergun

15 20 25
Re1 f1 exp f1 teo Re2 f2 exp f2 teo Re3 f3 exp
243.7 6.472 2.366 1389 14.6 1.858 632.3 5.029
487.4 3.143 2.058 2778 7.033 1.804 1265 4.275
731 3.156 1.955 4167 6.871 1.786 1897 1.855
974.7 2.8 1.904 5556 6.055 1.777 2529 1.679
1218 3.597 1.873 6945 8.546 1.772 3161 1.788
1462 3.28 1.853 8334 6.886 1.768 3794 1.6
1706 2.711 1.838 9723 6.224 1.765 4426 1.763
1949 2.588 1.827 11112 6.639 1.763 5058 1.66
2193 2.531 1.818 12501 6.642 1.762 5690 2.009
2437 2.53 1.812 13890 6.874 1.761 6323 1.668
2680 2.442 1.806 15278 6.966 1.76 6955 1.655
2924 2.447 1.801 16667 7.078 1.759 7587 1.924
f3 teo
1.987
1.869 𝒇𝒆𝒙𝒑, 𝒇𝒕𝒆𝒐 𝒗𝒔 𝑹𝒆𝑴𝑷
1.829 15
1.809 14
1.797 13
12
1.79 11
1.784 10
9
1.78
𝒇𝒆𝒙𝒑, 𝒇𝒕𝒆𝒐

8
1.776 7
6
1.774
5
1.772 4
1.77 3
2
1
0
100 900 1700 2500 3300 4100 4900 5700 6500 7300 8100 8900 9700 10500 11300 12100 12900 13700 14500
𝑹𝒆𝑴𝑷
𝑷

f1 exp
f1 teo
f2 exp
f2 teo
f3 exp
f3 teo

0500 11300 12100 12900 13700 14500 15300 16100 16900