Retoric i argumentare

2015-2016

Teme seminar
1. Susinerea n public a unui discurs de trei minute n care s se argumenteze persuasiv
alegerea variantei de criticism retoric, alegerea artefactului i alegerea ntrebrii
cercetrii; redactai varianta scris a discursului n dou pagini, cu un minim de dou
surse bibliografice sau electronice; putei include i informaii despre cum credei c
aceste alegeri v vor ajuta s susinei teza sau cum v vor ajuta s confirmai ori
infirmai ipoteza. Termene de susinere a discursurilor i de predare a lucrrii sunt: 21
octombrie, 28 octombrie i 4 noiembrie la orele de seminar.
2. Elaborarea unei lucrri de criticism retoric de minim cinci pagini, cu cinci surse
bibliografice sau electronice, care s se bazeze pe alegerile din tema 1 i s cuprind
cinci pri: introducerea, descrierea artefactului, descrierea metodei, analiza propriuzis i contribuia la teoria retoricii sau a comunicrii. (Lucrrile, parial elaborate, se
prezint n faa grupei, n cinci minute, n sptmna cnd este programat varianta de
criticism conform planului.) Termene limit de predare a lucrrii scrise sunt: 15
decembrie la ora de curs sau 16 decembrie la ora de seminar.
Lucrrile trebuie redactate n limba romn, font Times New Roman, caractere de 12, la 1.5
spaiu ntre rnduri, Justify. Nerespectarea termenelor limit conduce la depunctare sau
imposibilitatea obinerii unei note de activitate la seminar. Plagiatul conduce la exmatriculare.
Plan seminar
1. Introducere
2. Retorica i criticismul retoric (Foss, cap. 1)

Foss, S. K., 2009, Rhetorical Criticism. Exploration and Practice, ediia a IVa, Illinois, Waveland Long Grove, pp. 3-8.

Svulescu, S., 2004, Retorica i teoria argumentrii, Bucureti, Editura

comunicare, pp. 13-23.

Gaonkar, D. P., 2006, Introduction: Contingency and Probability, n W. Jost i

W. Olmsted (ed.), A Companion to Rhetoric and Rhetorical Criticism, WileyBlackwell Publishing, pp. 5-21.

3. Prile unei lucrri de criticism retoric (Foss, cap. 2; Bia, cap. 1; prezentare tem 1)

Foss, S. K., 2009, Rhetorical Criticism. Exploration and Practice, ediia a IVa, Illinois, Waveland Long Grove, pp. 9-17.

Bia, C., 2015, Introducere n criticismul retoric, n C. Bia (coord.) Arealul

criticismului retoric, Timioara, Editura Eurobit, pp. 5-30.

4. Criticismul retoric ca metod calitativ de cercetare (Black 3 pag.; susinere tem 1

i discuii)

Black, E., 2009, On Objectivity and Politics in Criticism, n Rhetorical

criticism. Perspectives in action, ed. J. A. Kuypers, Lanham, Lexington Books,
pp. 29-32.

Gabor, O. G., 2014, Politicul n parantez. Metode calitative de cercetare n

comunicarea intercultural, Iai, Editura Institutul European, pp. 13-25.

Kauffeld, F. J., 2001, Edwin Black on the Powers of the Rhetorical Critic, n J.
A. Kuypers i A. King (ed.), Twentieth-century Roots of Rhetorical Studies,
Westport, Praeger Publishers, pp. 235-273.

5. Criticismul retoric i argumentarea (Brockriede 10 pag. i de tradus; susinere tem 1

i discuii)

Brockriede, W., 1974, Rhetorical Criticism as Argument, n The Quarterly

Journal of Speech, 60, pp. 165-174.

Svulescu, S., 2004, Retorica i teoria argumentrii, Bucureti, Editura

comunicare, pp. 115-125.

Slvstru, C., 2003, Teoria i practica argumentrii, Iai, Polirom, pp. 66-84.

6. Situaia retoric (Bitzer 10 pag.; susinere tem 1 i discuii; prezentare tem 2)

Bitzer, L. F., 1968, The Rhetorical situation, n Philosophy and Rhetoric, vol.
1, nr. 1, pp. 1-14.

Farrell, K. i Young, M. J., 2009, The Rhetorical Situation, n J. A. Kuypers,

(ed.), Rhetorical Criticism. Perspectives in Action, Lanham, Lexington Books,
pp. 33-37.

Young, M. J., 2001, Lloyd F. Bitzer: Rhetorical Situation, Public Knowledge,

and Audience Dynamics, n J. A. Kuypers i A. King (ed.), Twentieth-century
Roots of Rhetorical Studies, Westport, Praeger Publishers, pp. 275-301.

7. Criticismul neo-aristotelian (Foss, cap. 3; Bia, cap. 12; susinere tem 2)

Foss, S. K., 2009, Rhetorical Criticism. Exploration and Practice, ediia a IV-a,
Illinois, Waveland Long Grove, pp. 21-28.

Bia, C., 2015, Introducere n criticismul retoric, n C. Bia (coord.), Arealul

criticismului retoric, Timioara, Editura Eurobit, pp. 191-213.

Gabor, O. G., 2015, Criticismul retoric n tiinele comunicrii. Atelier pentru

un vis, Iai, Editura Institutul European, pp. 112-147.

Hill, F. I., 2009, The Traditional Perspective, n J. A. Kuypers, (ed.),

Rhetorical Criticism. Perspectives in Action, Lanham, Lexington Books, pp. 3961.

Griffin, E., 2012, A First Look at Communication Theory, ediia a VIII-a, New
York, McGrow-Hill, pp. 289-298.

West, R.; Turner, L, 2010, Introducing Communication Theory: Analysis and

Application (ediia a IV-a), Boston, McGraaw-Hill, pp. 310-327.

8. Criticismul cuvintelor-cheie (Foss, cap. 4; susinere tem 2)

Foss, S. K., 2009, Rhetorical Criticism. Exploration and Practice, ediia a IV-a,
Illinois, Waveland Long Grove, pp. 63-69.

Gabor, O. G., 2015, Criticismul retoric n tiinele comunicrii. Atelier pentru

un vis, Iai, Editura Institutul European, pp. 166-211.

Anderson, F. D, King, A. i McClure K., 2009, Kenneth Burkes Dramatic Form

Criticism, n J. A. Kuypers, (ed.), Rhetorical Criticism. Perspectives in Action,
Lanham, Lexington Books, pp. 143-163.

Griffin, E., 2012, A First Look at Communication Theory, ediia a VIII-a, New
York, McGrow-Hill, pp. 299-307.

9. Criticismul pentadic (Foss, cap. 10; susinere tem 2)

Foss, S. K., 2009, Rhetorical Criticism. Exploration and Practice, ediia a IV-a,
Illinois, Waveland Long Grove, pp. 355-364.

King, A., 2009, Pentadic Criticism: The Wheels of Creation, n J. A. Kuypers,

(ed.), Rhetorical Criticism. Perspectives in Action, Lanham, Lexington Books,
pp. 165-179.

West, R.; Turner, L, 2010, Introducing Communication Theory: Analysis and

Application (ediia a IV-a), Boston, McGraaw-Hill, pp. 328-342.

10. Criticismul narativ (Foss, cap. 9; susinere tem 2)

Foss, S. K., 2009, Rhetorical Criticism. Exploration and Practice, ediia a IV-a,
Illinois, Waveland Long Grove, pp. 307-317.

Gabor, O. G., 2015, Criticismul retoric n tiinele comunicrii. Atelier pentru

un vis, Iai, Editura Institutul European, pp. 211-249.

Rowland, R., 2009, The Narrative Perspective, n J. A. Kuypers, (ed.),

Rhetorical Criticism. Perspectives in Action, Lanham, Lexington Books, pp.
117-142.

Griffin, E., 2012, A First Look at Communication Theory, ediia a VIII-a, New
York, McGrow-Hill, pp. 308-317.

West, R.; Turner, L, 2010, Introducing Communication Theory: Analysis and

Application (ediia a IV-a), Boston, McGraaw-Hill, pp. 343-358.

11. Criticismul imaginarului tematic i criticismul metaforic (Foss, cap. 5 i 8; susinere

tem 2)

Foss, S. K., 2009, Rhetorical Criticism. Exploration and Practice, ediia a IV-a,
Illinois, Waveland Long Grove, pp. 97-103.

Foss, S. K., 2009, Rhetorical Criticism. Exploration and Practice, ediia a IV-a,
Illinois, Waveland Long Grove, pp. 267-274.

St. Antoine, T. J., Althouse, M. T. i Ball M. A., 2009, Fantasy-Theme

Criticism, n J. A. Kuypers, (ed.), Rhetorical Criticism. Perspectives in Action,
Lanham, Lexington Books, pp. 205-230.

Ball M. A, 2001, Ernest G. Bormann: Roots, Revelations, and Results of

Symbolic Convergence Theory, n J. A. Kuypers i A. King (ed.), Twentiethcentury Roots of Rhetorical Studies, Westport, Praeger Publishers, pp. 211-233.

Griffin, E., 2012, A First Look at Communication Theory, ediia a VIII-a, New
York, McGrow-Hill, pp. 247-258.

Burkholder, T. R. i Henry, D., 2009, Criticism of Metaphor, n J. A. Kuypers,

(ed.), Rhetorical Criticism. Perspectives in Action, Lanham, Lexington Books,
pp. 97-115.

12. Criticismul generic i ideologic (Foss, cap. 6 i 7; susinere tem 2; predarea lucrrilor
pentru tema 2)

Foss, S. K., 2009, Rhetorical Criticism. Exploration and Practice, ediia a IV-a,
Illinois, Waveland Long Grove, pp. 137-145 i 209-220.

Benoit, W., 2009, Generic Elements in Rhetoric, n J. A. Kuypers, (ed.),

Rhetorical Criticism. Perspectives in Action, Lanham, Lexington Books, pp. 7795.

Lee, R., 2009, Ideographic Criticism, n J. A. Kuypers, (ed.), Rhetorical

Criticism. Perspectives in Action, Lanham, Lexington Books, pp. 285-319.

13. Discutarea lucrrilor i exerciii de argumentare

Svulescu, S., 2004, Retorica i teoria argumentrii, Bucureti, Editura

comunicare, pp. 131-140.

Warburton, N., 1999, Cum s gndim corect i eficient, Bucureti, Editura Trei.

14. Discutarea lucrrilor i exerciii de argumentare

Svulescu, S., 2004, Retorica i teoria argumentrii, Bucureti, Editura

comunicare, pp. 143-168.

Slvstru, C., 2003, Teoria i practica argumentrii, Iai, Polirom.

Bibliografie obligatorie
Bia, C., (coord.), 2015, Arealul criticismului retoric, Timioara, Editura Eurobit.
Foss, S. K., 2009, Rhetorical Criticism. Exploration and Practice, ediia a IV-a, Illinois,
Waveland Long Grove.
Gabor, O. G., 2015, Criticismul retoric n tiinele comunicrii. Atelier pentru un vis, Iai,
Editura Institutul European.
Kuypers, J. A. (ed.), 2009, Rhetorical Criticism. Perspectives in Action, Lanham, Lexington
Books.
Svulescu, S., 2004, Retorica i teoria argumentrii, Bucureti, Editura comunicare.
Bibliografie general
Aristotel, 2004, Retorica, Bucureti, Editura Iri.
Aristotel, 1997, Organon I, Bucureti, Editura Iri.
Aristotel, 1998, Organon II, Bucureti, Editura Iri.
Berkun, S., 2012, Confesiunile unui vorbitor public, Bucureti, Editura Publica.
Black, E., 2009, On Objectivity and Politics in Criticism. n Rhetorical criticism. Perspectives
in action, ed. J. A. Kuypers, 29-32. Lanham: Lexington Books.
Browne, M. N. i Keeley, S. M., 2007, Asking the Right Questions: A Guide to Critical
Thinking (ediia a VIII-a), New Jersey, Upper Saddle River.
Burgchardt, C. R. (ed.), 2010, Readings In Rhetorical Criticism, ediia a IV-a, Pennsylvania,
Strata Publishing.

Campbell, K. K., Huxman, S. S. i Burkholder, T. R., 2015, The Rhetorical Act: Thinking,
Speaking,and Writing Critically (ediia a V-a), Stamford, Cangage Learning.
Carnegie, D., 2000, Cum vorbim n public, Bucureti, Editura Curtea Veche.
Cazacu, A. M., 2007, Teoria argumentrii, Bucureti, Romnia Press.
Florescu, V., 1973, Retorica i neoretorica: genez, evoluie, perspective, Bucureti, Editura
Academiei Romne.
Foucault, M., 1998, Ordinea discursului, Bucureti, Editura Eurosong & Book.
Fraleigh D. M., i Tuman, J. S., 2011, Speak up, Boston, New York, Bedford, St. Martins.
Gabor, O. G., 2014, Politicul n parantez. Metode calitative de cercetare n comunicarea
intercultural, Iai, Editura Institutul European.
Griffin, E., 2012, A First Look at Communication Theory, ediia a VIII-a, New York, McGrowHill.
Hart R. P. i Daughton, R. P., 2005, Modern Rhetorical Criticism, ediia a III-a, Boston,
Pearson Education.
Heath, C. i Heath D., 2008, Idei cu impact garantat: de ce unele idei supravieuiesc, iar altele
dispar, Bucureti, Editura Curtea Veche.
Heinrichs, J., 2007, Thank You for Arguing, New York, Three Rivers Press.
Herrick, J. A., 2013, The History and Theory of Rhetoric: An Introduction (ediia a V-a),
Boston, Pearson.
Hoff, R., 2002, Regulile unei prezentri de succes, Bucureti, Editura Curtea Veche.
Jost, W. i Olmsted, W. (ed.), 2006, A Companion to Rhetoric and Rhetorical Criticism, WileyBlackwell Publishing.
Kuypers, J. A. i King, A. (ed.), 2001, Twentieth-century Roots of Rhetorical Studies, Westport,
Praeger Publishers.
Kuypers, J. A. (ed.), 2009, Rhetorical Criticism. Perspectives in Action, Lanham, Lexington
Books.
Lanham, L. A., 1991, A Handlist of Rhetorical Terms (ediia a II-a), Berkeley, University of
California Press.
Littlejohn S. W. i Foss, K. A. (ed.), 2009, Encyclopedia of Communication Theory, Los
Angeles, Washington DC, Sage.
Lucas, S., 2014, Arta de a vorbi n public, Iai, Editura Polirom.
Marga, A., 2002, Introducere n filosofia contemporan, Iai, Polirom.
Meyer, M., 2010, Principia Rhetorica. Teoria general a argumentrii, Iai, Editura
Universitii Al. I. Cuza.

Ott, B. i Dickinson, G. (ed.), 2012, The Routledge Reader in Rhetorical Criticism Paperback,
Routledge.
Padron, P., 2012, Cum vorbim n public: exerciii de oratorie, Bucureti, Editura Universitar.
Perelman, C. i Olbrechts-Tyteca, L., 2012, Tratat de argumentare. Noua retoric, Iai, Editura
Universitii Al. I. Cuza.
Petcu, M., (coord.), 2014, Dicionar enciclopedic de comunicare i termeni asociai, Bucureti,
Editura C.H. Beck.
Reynolds, G., 2011, Presentation Zen: idei simple despre designul i susinerea prezentrilor,
Bucureti, Editura Publica.
Reynolds, G., 2010, Presentation Zen design simple design principles and techniques to
enhance your presentations, Berkeley, New Riders.
Pink, D., 2015, O minte cu totul nou: De ce right-brainers vor guverna viitorul, Bucureti,
Curtea Veche.
Pirie, M., 2006, How to Win Every Argument: The Use and Abuse of Logic, Londra,
Continuum.
Rozakis, L., 2007, Cum vorbim n public, Bucureti, Editura Curtea Veche.
Slvstru, C., 2003, Teoria i practica argumentrii, Iai, Polirom.
Schopenhauer, A., 2011, Arta de a avea ntotdeauna dreptate, Bucureti, Editura Art.
Sloane, T. O., (ed.), 2001, Encyclopedia of Rhetoric, Oxford, Oxford University Press.
Smith, C. R., 2009, Rhetoric and Human Consciousness: A History, Long Grove, Waveland
Press.
Toit, Paul du. 2012. Secretul prezentrilor de succes. Bucureti: Editura Curtea Veche.
Toulmin, S., 2003, The Uses of Argument, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Walton, D., 2007, Media Argumentation: Dialectic, Persuasion, and Rhetoric, Cambridge,
Cambridge University Press.
Warburton, N., 1999, Cum s gndim corect i eficient, Bucureti, Editura Trei.
West, R. i Turner, L., 2010, Introducing Communication Theory: Analysis and Application
(ediia a IV-a), Boston, McGraaw-Hill.

Resurse electronice
Reynolds, G., Presentation Zen: How to Design & Deliver Presentations Like a Pro, accesat
la 29.09.2015.

XXX,

Survey

of

Communication

Study/Chapter

Rhetorical

https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Survey_of_Communication_Study/Chapter_7__Rhetorical_Criticism, accesat la 29.09.2015.

XXX, www.citatepedia.com, accesat la 29.09.2015.
XXX, www.ted.com, accesat la 29.09.2015.

Criticism,